The Nine Lawsuits for Religious Freedom: A Brief Rundown of the Arguments

There are now nine lawsuits, including one brought by Priests for Life, which have been filed in federal district courts around the country challenging the Obama administration’s HHS mandate that requires employers to provide coverage for activities that many of them believe people should not do.

There is value to having multiple lawsuits, because, having been introduced in different judicial jurisdictions around the country, some may be victorious and others not, hence setting up a federal conflict that the Supreme Court is more likely to address.

There are similarities and differences in the legal arguments of the nine lawsuits.

First Amendment – Religious Liberty

The first and most obvious objection to the mandate is that it infringes on the free exercise of religion which the Constitution guarantees to every American.  The mandate forces health insurers, employers, and employees to violate their own religious faiths by providing or purchasing items and services that their faiths strictly prohibit.  Moreover, it penalizes the practice of religion by imposing hefty government fines on employers who stop providing employee health insurance rather than deny their beliefs.  This is exactly the type of government behavior that the First Amendment was designed to prevent.

Religious Freedom Restoration Act

A second argument is that the mandate violates the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).  This 1993 law stops the federal government from restricting religious belief unless it can show a “compelling government interest” for doing so.  Providing subsidized abortifacients, birth control, and sterilization hardly seems to be a “compelling government interest” to interfere in religion.

First Amendment – Free Speech

Another common cause of action in the nine lawsuits is that the Obamacare mandate violates the free speech clause of the First Amendment.  Not only does the mandate force employers and employees to pay for objectionable items and procedures, but they also have to fund education and counseling for those same things.  In other words, people of faith would be forced to endorse with their involuntary financial contributions speech that contradicts their beliefs.

Administrative Procedure Act

The lawsuits by Priests for Life and others also allege that the Obama administration’s actions in putting forth the mandate for abortifacient/contraceptive coverage did not follow proper government procedures.

Overburdening State Medicaid Programs

The lawsuit brought by seven states, Bruning v. Sebelius, adds that state Medicaid programs will be overrun with new enrollees because of the mandate.  The states argue that religiously affiliated employers will either stop offering health insurance or, because they cannot afford the government fines for not offering employee health insurance, shut down completely.  The result of either action will be more people without health insurance, which under Obamacare, will mean more people moving to Medicaid coverage.  The increased financial strain on state budgets will be enormous.

Cardinal Timothy Dolan has pointed out that the courts are likely the best defense against the HHS mandate.  May God give success to the efforts of Priests for Life, other religiously affiliated employers, religious individuals, states, and even a private commercial business who have all brought suits to stop this mandate.

For more information on the mandate and the lawsuits, see

12 Responses to “The Nine Lawsuits for Religious Freedom: A Brief Rundown of the Arguments”

  1. Coach Factory says:

    You can still find many old styles of Coach Factory bags in Coach Outlet Online, while they could not be found in the Coach Factory Outlet.

  2. coach factory outlet says:

    No one can deny the shopping at the coach factory outlet is satisfactory. For the low prices and good quality.Are you anxious to choose some of the brand bags? Are you searching for reliable sellers? When you come to the coach factory outlet online, these are not problems.The net is the most beneficial useful resource you’ll be able to use to uncover your nearest coach factory online outlet. you are guaranteed an excellent discount.

  3. louis vuitton outlet says:

    Have you ever dreamed of being as charming as Madonna? Have you ever thought of becoming an envy of all your friends? If so, come to Louis Vuitton Outlet. It is so good and attractive as a result of being made by a stylish designer or more. None can say no in front of so popular and chic louis vuitton online shop. It is the best time for you to match clothing in this summer afternoon, carrying with the new louis vuitton handbags in louis vuitton online shop.

  4. coach outlet store says:

    My friend is dying to get a coach purse at Coach Outlet Store because all of her friends have them at work. They earn great reputation from many people. It’s wonderful to find out it does not slip in your signature at the bottom of the case and the appearance of brass accents from Coach Outlet Online, Because women who can look stylish this summer. There are different kinds of crossbody bags within marketplace nowadays. Even so it is not possible to beat the timeless design jointly with traditional elegance of the Bags at the Coach Outlet Online Store .

  5. mujeres site says:

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really great articles and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d really like to write some articles for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an e-mail if interested. Thank you!

  6. Coach Outlet says:

    combine quality, durability, efficiency.

  7. Coaching für Führungskräfte says:

    Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and
    wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
    In any case I’ll be subscribing on your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!

  8. Ralph Lauren says:

    Ralph Lauren entrée de sorte que vous pouvez concevoir lieu pattern et the model prises alors que dans the mettre avec sa cravate Lover Brummel autour de 1967. Dans cette point, l’ensemble

  9. Louis Vuitton says:

    Insieme minus l . a . crescita delete marchio della condizione, è quella di no Nervosismo on diretta sui prodotti contraffatti è una sfida centrale each and every l’azienda. Cessa di vivere LV simbolo è stato prodotto each and every scoraggiare as i falsari di ricostruire il start looking unico product. Mum questo sarà ancora da raccogliere di conseguenza molte persone che cessano di vivere forgiato sul 40′s dei risultati benefici di marca. Molti di questi contraffatta borsa Louis Vuitton sono molto costosi each and every l . a . sfortuna di coloro che l . a . sfortuna di comprare, no cuando può farne an important meno. Quindi l . a . società è preoccupato each and every l . a . sfida di falsificazione, che travolgenti misure adottate each and every affrontare questa sfida. Secondo una storia 2006 delete quotidiano britannico stampata, as i cambiamenti, i quindi ci sono circa sixty one dipendenti, il cui obiettivo primario è quello di cercare su anelli di contraffazione. Questa società sta andando each and every no essere defraudato di denaro, to vedere l . a . loro clientela ingannati dai pirati avidi.

    I tuttavia, l . a . società no è di circa il rischio, fallimento, on quanto cuando stima essere miliardi i miliardi di Expense. L . a . sua lunga storia di riconoscimento i no mancano mai di stupire gli amanti della moda, as i volti familiari i attenti alla moda donne on tutto il mondo. Minus stile fresco i model, pezzi moderni i billy noto di pezzi traditional stabiliti, il Gruppo Louis Vuitton, each and every mantenere l . a . sua Chiamato take place n’t cessate il top notch dealer Ofin an important vivere di alta moda delete mondo. As i suoi articoli di lusso, collezioni di bagagli i borse continuano l . a . loro ascesa. Oggi, pancia di inizio i di piste an important store di stilisti alla family home camere spogliatoi delle donne provenienti da tutti as i ceti sociali, borse di Louis Vuitton sono n’t fondamentale di coloro che cessano di vivere il negozio di Louis Vuitton pratica commerciale i nice i popular assumere cessare di vivere Pattern apprezzare. I ze volete una borsa Louis Vuitton, alla ricerca di una tariffa ragionevole intorno an important una borsa all’ingrosso, quindi, cuando può possedere n’t piccolo pezzo di grande model.

  10. Lauren says:

    After going over a number of the blog articles on your web page, I seriously like your
    technique of blogging. I saved it to my bookmark webpage list
    and will be checking back soon. Take a look at my website too and tell me your opinion.

  11. coach outlet says:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts about coach outlet.

  12. Louis Vuitton Canada says:

    No matter wherever you buy your discount designer merchandise, continuously take care that the vendor is honourable. If you’re shopping for from virtual stores on the online, look to envision if the vendor has Louis Vuitton Canada any complaints lodged against them.

Leave a Comment