Preaching on Abortion
Fr. Frank Pavone
National Director, Priests for Life
Where are our people on abortion?
What Do We Need to Convince People of?
Love the Angry
Configured to Christ the Head
The Bread of Life
The Greatest Obstacle to Abortion
A System of Communication
Preaching to the Choir
Expanding upon Some Specific Passages
Partial List of Individual Scripture references
The Holy Spirit
The Virgin Mary
A Tragedy beyond words
Priests for Life Resources for Preaching on abortion
There is a lot of pain in our midst…pain regarding the tragedy of abortion.
We as priests share in that pain. We are also called to address it. Dealing with
it is an essential aspect of our call to serve the needs of our people.
Some of the pain of abortion comes from having been involved in one.
Some of the pain, on the other hand, comes from simply knowing it
happens. Most people understand abortion is wrong. But because they know that
doing something to stop it will involve sacrifices they would rather not make,
they don't really make an effort to learn more about it. Facing abortion
directly, after all, will make them feel worse about not doing something about
In the midst of this dilemma, we are called and sent as priests.
We are called to bring hope, reconciliation, and healing to those who
have procured or cooperated in abortions. We are also called to encourage and
equip our people to make positive changes in society, so that respect and
protection for the lives of our unborn brothers and sisters will flourish.
A priest is a minister of truth and compassion, two realities which, far
from being contrary to each other, are essential aspects of each other. God,
after all, is both Truth and Compassion itself, and He is One.
To fail in compassion for the weakness and suffering of our people is to
fail to reflect the truth about their lives and the truth about God's love.
To fail to bear witness to the truth, in all its clarity and vigor, is to
fail in compassion, because people have a need for truth. It is as necessary for
the growth of the spirit as food is for the body.
These pages are meant to help you preach, in truth and compassion, about
what the United States bishops have called "the fundamental human rights issue
of our day," that is, abortion (Resolution on Abortion, 1989). These reflections
provide a springboard, a stimulus to prayerful thought, from which you will then
be able to build a fruitful ministry of pro-life preaching adapted to the
concrete situation in which you serve.
As National Director of Priests for Life, I have preached about abortion in a
different part of the country every week since 1993, and have been in all 50
states. I can summarize the reaction I receive from people in two words: "Thank
you!" People are grateful to hear the truth spoken in compassion.
They are grateful when we, their priests, can help them deal intelligently
and courageously with the pain that abortion brings to all of us. We pray that
these pages will help you do precisely that.
Fr. Frank Pavone
Priests for Life
Love Them Both: How to Preach About Abortion
"Father, I came into this Church this morning being totally pro-abortion,
and the homily changed my views completely."
"Father, I had an abortion, and sometimes it hurts to hear about it, but
please keep up the preaching! I gladly endure whatever pain I have, because I
know the homilies will keep some other woman from ever going through what I have
gone through from the abortion itself."
"Hi! I’d like to begin this letter by thanking you for last week’s homily. I
was deeply moved and so was my younger brother. I’m 17 and he’s 12. We did not
fully understand what goes on in abortion till your homily. We both would like
to get on the mailing lists of pro-life organizations."
These are three of the thousands of reactions I have received after
preaching about abortion over the last several years. The reactions cited above
are characteristic of the content and tone of the others as well.
How do we preach on abortion? What are we trying to accomplish? How do we
awaken our people to this immense evil? How do we handle reactions of anger and
Where are our people on abortion?
A good place to start answering these questions is to examine the
attitudes of the American people on abortion. Sometimes we hear that "Most
Americans are pro-choice." The statement is meaningless until the term
"pro-choice" is defined. A more helpful way to understand what most people think
is to ask them the specific circumstances in which they think abortion should be
That is precisely what was done in a survey conducted by the Wirthlin Group
in June of 1999. About 11% said they thought abortion should be prohibited in
all circumstances, and about the same number said it should be legal at any time
during pregnancy, and for any reason. There were four other positions. Most of
the remaining people said abortion should be legal only in cases of rape,
incest, or danger to the mother’s life, with a somewhat smaller number saying it
should only be legal to save the mother’s life. The other two positions were
that it should be legal for any reason but not after the first three months of
pregnancy, and that it should be legal for any reason but not after the first
six months of pregnancy.
By the admission of the Alan Guttmacher Institute, the abortions in cases of
rape or incest account for about 1% of the total abortions. By the testimony of
many medical experts, furthermore, abortion is never necessary to save a
Conclusion? Most Americans oppose 99% of the abortions taking place,
while the current policy on abortion (available through all nine months) is
supported by about 11% of the public.
We likewise see the curious phenomenon that among the majority of
Americans who would oppose most abortions but permit some, there is a growing
number of those who are willing to admit that the abortions they would consider
justified are the killing of human beings. In a 1989 Los Angeles Times poll, in
fact, 57% called abortion "murder," including one-fourth of those who also said
they "generally favored abortion." In 1998, a CBS/NY Times poll indicated that
some 50% of the respondents were willing to call abortion "murder," yet
one-third of those people said it is sometimes the best course of action for the
woman to take.
What is going on here? Why are there so many abortions when most people
oppose them and even admit what they are?
First of all, people have gotten the message from the pro-life movement
that abortion kills a baby. They have also gotten the message from the
abortion-rights side that sometimes abortion benefits women, who should not be
deprived of the benefit. Having accepted both messages, the majority of
Americans belong to the "conflicted middle." Where this group ultimately goes is
where America will ultimately go on abortion.
The other phenomenon at work is denial fueled by pain. There are more
each day who are directly involved in an abortion decision, and are therefore at
least initially not eager to get involved in an effort to either expose what it
is or stop it.
There is an even larger number, however, whose pain over abortion is not
because of direct personal involvement, but because of a dilemma that was best
described by one who said, "When people know enough to realize that to learn
a little more will involve some risk, it is amazing to see how little they want
to learn." People know abortion is happening, but also realize that if they
look at it too directly, they will not be able to live at peace with themselves
unless they start to do something to stop it. At the same time, they know that
if they try to stop it, there will be a price to pay. They may lose friends or
face other kinds of opposition. They don’t want to make the sacrifice necessary
to confront injustice. What, then, is their solution to this dilemma? Ignore the
problem altogether. Denial protects them from the pain of the situation. This is
why some people become angry when the topic of abortion is raised. They were
succeeding in ignoring it and someone brought it to the surface.
What Do We Need to Convince People of?
Given the attitudes people have on abortion, and the dominant images they
have about the pro-life effort, we can begin to trace several themes we need to
communicate as we preach on this topic.
People need to know that we are on their side. A discussion of
abortion, whether in private or public, should acknowledge the pain that most of
us feel about it, whether we describe ourselves as pro-life or not. The
psychological attitude to take and to convey is, "You are not my enemy. We are
in this painful situation together, and need to help each other out of it." The
individual who may react angrily to a pro-life homily is best approached with a
frame of mind similar to which we care for those afflicted by personal
disasters. We are dealing with good people who have pain, not with enemies.
People need to know that to be pro-life is to be pro-woman. The
difference between "pro-life" and "pro-choice" is not that pro-lifers love the
baby and pro-choicers love the woman. The difference is that the "pro-choice"
message says you can separate the two and the pro-life message says you cannot.
Pro-lifers are criticized for being "fetus-lovers" who are insensitive to women.
But one cannot, and pro-lifers do not, love the child without loving the mother.
Abortion defenders claim they are loving women, even as they admit they are
killing their children. But one cannot love the woman without loving the child.
Nor can one harm the child without harming the mother.
The message must be clear that to be pro-life means to be pro-woman, and that
the challenge the pro-life movement gives to society is, "Why can’t we love them
both?" One reason why many who think abortion is wrong will not actively oppose
it is that they think they have to make a choice between defending the rights of
the baby or those of the mother, or that they have to consider the baby as more
important than the mother. But the authentic pro-life message is a message of
equality. It is a challenge to expand the circle of our love, welcome,
and protection. This insight helps resolve the conflict of the "conflicted
middle" who see the evil of abortion but think it benefits women.
People need to know that to oppose abortion does not mean to oppose
those who have them. An aspect of the pro-woman theme of our pro-life
preaching is the healing and forgiveness the Church and the pro-life movement
offer to those who have been involved in abortion. In most of my homilies, I
mention the real case of a woman who had 24 abortions, and proclaim that even
for her, the doors of the Church are open!
The Church has the perfect spiritual and psychological balance necessary
for those who have been involved in an abortion. The last thing such a person
needs to here is, "What you did is no big deal." The nature of post-abortion
grief is that the individual involved in the abortion has begun to realize
precisely what a big deal it was! Now this person needs someone to tell her that
she should not feel silly for feeling sad, that there is indeed reason for the
grief in her heart, and that what her heart is telling her is true: her child
was killed. A great disservice was done both to her and her child when someone
convinced her that the abortion would be "no big deal." Accepting that line was
a major act of denial. Healing now begins when she breaks out of denial and
calls the evil what it is. The clear preaching of the Church about abortion
helps her to do this.
At the same time, the other line she does not need to hear is, "You are
rejected; there is no hope." As she realizes the evil that has occurred, she
will be tempted to say this to herself. The Church, however, contradicts that
despair with the clear message of forgiveness, echoed recently by the Holy
Father in Evangelium Vitae #99. The Church accompanies all who have been
involved in abortion, whether the mother, father, grandparents, or even the
abortion provider, to the forgiveness and healing Christ offers.
Those in the pain of abortion are not helped by silence. Some refrain
from preaching about abortion out of the sincere motive of not hurting women who
have had abortions. Yet that silence does not interpret itself. The person
grieving over abortion can infer from our silence that we do not know her pain,
or that we do not care, or that there is no hope. None of this is true. By our
clear and compassionate homilies we can break through the silence which led her
to this disastrous choice in the first place.
People need to know that abortion is their business. The key challenge
in presenting our people with the abortion issue is not so much convincing them
that it is wrong, but rather convincing them that it is any of their business.
Abortion defenders will say, "If you are against abortion, fine…don't have one.
But leave the rest of us alone to exercise our own beliefs and make our own
choices." Many people who oppose abortion will therefore lament it, but will
feel out of place trying to stop it. They see it as wrong, but as a private
wrong, with which it is none of their business to interfere.
One of the key tasks necessary here is to de-isolate the issue. People
understand that we have to intervene to help the poor, the AIDS victim, the drug
addict, the victim of crime and war. Even if we do not know their names, or have
never seen the faces of these victims, we know it is our business to help them.
We do not hear people say, "I would never abuse my child, but if the other
person wants to do so, that’s her choice." The reason people do not say that is
that they realize that some choices have victims. When somebody’s choice
destroys or threatens somebody else’s life, that’s everyone’s business. It is,
after all, the business of love, which intervenes to save our brothers and
sisters in need. There, precisely, is the reason it is both our business and our
privilege to work to stop abortions.
People need to know that there is something they can do to stop
abortion. All of the above is not yet enough. Many oppose abortion but do
not think anything can be done. If we awaken people to the evil but do not guide
their response, they will either end up depressed or perhaps act irresponsibly.
The problem is not that there is nothing that can be done, but that there are
not enough people doing the perfectly legal, peaceful and effective activities
they can do to end abortion. Presenting such options in the homily, and
following up on them through well-organized parish respect life programs, will
overcome another obstacle to the involvement of many in this cause: they think
of the pro-life movement as an extreme and fanatical movement characterized by
activities they want nothing to do with.
How do we convey all this in 10 or 15 minutes?
-- Three Elements for a
A very convincing homily can be given in ten minutes conveying the points
mentioned above and incorporating the strategic elements I have explained.
(Priests for Life offers specific homily training in the form of written
materials, audio and video tapes, and seminars, and has been quite well received
in dioceses all over the country.)
The basic homily structure I have used around the nation consists, in
conjunction with the readings, of three major points in the following order:
- There are alternatives to abortion. Those who procure abortions
do not do so because of "freedom of choice," but rather because they feel
they have no freedom and no choice. Many are "pro-choice" not because they
like abortion but because they ask, "How can the woman live without it?" The
good news is that the Church and pro-life movement are providing better
choices than abortion, and that a wide range of help is available for anyone
who needs it. Thousands of helping centers provide financial assistance,
medical services, legal advice, counseling, a place to live, jobs,
education, and assistance to keep the child or to place the child for
adoption. People at Mass can be asked to take a handout which has phone
numbers of abortion-alternatives which they can pass on to those who might
need them. It is amazing to see how many people who know that the Church
opposes abortion are unaware of the Church’s willingness to provide
alternatives. This makes them feel good about being a Catholic and about
helping the pro-life movement. By mentioning the point about alternatives
first, a major objection is tackled before it arises: "What are you who
oppose abortion going to do to help the woman who needs it?"
- Stress that the Church offers forgiveness and healing after abortion.
This is critical, because so many feel they cannot be forgiven. If all the
abortions ended tomorrow, the mission of healing will have only begun. The
Gospel of Life is a Gospel of Mercy. The hope of mercy, furthermore,
prevents additional abortions, since there are significant psychological
dynamics whereby despair leads to repeat abortions. (Some 46% of abortions
in America are repeat abortions.) Furthermore, many hesitate to become
active in the pro-life movement because they think that to oppose abortion
means to oppose those who have had them, and they do not want to compromise
their relationship with their sister, cousin, or friend. If they see that
being pro-life means embracing these women with forgiveness, they may be
more inclined to join the effort. There is a National Office for
Post-Abortion Reconciliation and Healing at 1-800-5-WE-CARE.
- Help people to see through the slogans which make tolerance of abortion
seem so reasonable. The term "Pro-choice," for example, fails to point to
what is chosen, and would never be applied to child abuse or violent crime.
Some choices have victims, including the choice of abortion. "Safe and legal
abortion" is a slogan which misleads people into thinking that if it is
legal, it must be safe, and to keep it safe we need to keep it legal. Yet
the abortion industry is the most unregulated surgical industry in the
nation, and regularly destroys the health and lives of the women who procure
it in legal facilities. Also focus on some basic facts that most people do
not know: there is an abortion every 20 seconds in America; it is legal and
happens through all nine months of pregnancy; less than 1% occur because of
rape or incest.
The practical follow-up to the homily is a handout I mention when I
talk about alternatives. It is a Priests for Life brochure entitled You Can
Save Someone’s Life Today! It contains dozens of practical things people can
do to help stop abortions, including toll-free numbers (like 1-800-848-LOVE)
that can be dialed from anywhere in the nation and have a live person at the
other end 24 hours a day to provide counseling and any type of assistance for
those who are tempted to have abortions or who have had them. This handout is
placed at all the exits of the Church, and everyone is asked to take it home,
read it, keep it, and use it. I have received letters explaining that the
handout was used successfully to persuade a person not to have an abortion.
Love the Angry
A few will react angrily no matter how abortion is spoken about, for
reasons described above. In all my preaching on abortion, however, I can still
count on one hand the number of those who came to me angry because of a pro-life
homily. The best way to approach them, using the attitude described earlier, is
to gently ask them questions so as to draw out of them the cause for their anger
and help them think about it. I invite them to sit down in an out-of-the-way
place to talk calmly. Some will do that, others will leave. But it is much
harder to criticize or be angry with someone who wants to listen to you
than with someone who either lectures you or responds with anger as well. Let
them know that you are listening, that you know their pain, and that the message
of respect for life which you will steadfastly preach also says that their life
is precious, too, no matter what they disagree with.
At the Heart of the
-- Links between Priesthood and Pro-life Ministry
Priesthood and pro-life ministry are essentially linked, for the reason that
the Holy Father points out in Evangelium Vitae, "The Gospel of God's love for
man, the Gospel of the dignity of the person and the Gospel of life are a single
and indivisible Gospel" (EV #3). Defending the dignity of the human person is
not a task "added onto" our ministry, but rather one inseparable from it, and
flowing from its very heart.
Christ gives Himself away on the cross and in the Eucharist, and there
we find the meaning of love: I sacrifice myself for the good of the other
person. This is the perfect reversal of abortion, which says, I sacrifice
the other person for the good of myself. The same words,
in fact, that the Lord and His priests use to proclaim love are used by the
defenders of abortion: This is my body. Some say they control their
bodies, and so others must die; Christ says He gives His Body away, so others
may live. This is my body, given up for you. In the power of these words,
the culture of death will be transformed into the culture of life.
By considering from various angles how pro-life ministry flows from our
priesthood, we can develop the context in which we can then consider the place
pro-life issues have in our preaching.
Configured to Christ the Head
The priest is "another Christ," and as such is a man of salvation, bringing
others the benefits of the Redemption. Yet the priest is also a man of creation,
for Christ not only saved the world, but made it. The earliest New Testament
reference to this is 1 Corinthians 8:6, "For us there is... one Lord, Jesus
Christ through Whom all things are and through Whom we exist." Colossians
reiterates the theme. "All things were created through Him and for Him. He is
before all else that is, and in Him everything continues in being"
(Col.1:16-17). It is the message of John's Prologue. "In the beginning was the
Word.... All things came to be through Him, and without Him nothing came to be.
What came to be in Him was life...(John 1:1-3; See also Heb.1:2; Prov.8:30).
Christ is Alpha and Omega (Rev. 22:13); He is the beginning of life and the
purpose of life. He is the answer to the child's question, "Mommy, why are there
stars and mountains and people?" To stand for Christ is to stand for creation
and for life; to minister Christ to the world is to minister life. The pre-born
child exists through Him and for Him. To be silent about that child's
destruction is to betray both the child and Christ. To bring salvation to God's
people is first of all to defend their very existence.
The prophecies of Christ are heavily linked with the word "justice." Psalm 72
declares, "Justice shall flower in his days, and profound peace till the moon be
no more," and then specifies what that justice entails: "He shall rescue the
poor man when he has no one to help him.... From fraud and violence he shall
redeem them, and precious shall their blood be in his sight" (v. 7, 12, 14).
"Justice" refers to an act of intervention for the defenseless. God does it for
His people, and His people must do it for one another. If they don't, worship of
God is pointless. This is brought out forcefully through the prophet Amos, when
God says, "I hate, I spurn your feasts, I take no pleasure in your
solemnities.... Away with your noisy songs! I will not listen to the melodies of
your harps. But if you would offer me holocausts, then let justice surge like
water, and goodness like an unfailing stream" (Amos 5:21, 23-24. See also Isaiah
Christ preaches and acts in the name of justice, declaring that the Spirit of
the Lord has anointed Him to free the oppressed (Luke 4:18 from Is. 61). In His
ministry, Christ seeks out those whom society oppresses and rejects: the poor,
the lepers, the lunatics, the tax collectors and sinners, and the children whom
even His apostles considered troublesome.
His justice, ultimately, is "to undo the works of the devil" (1 John 3:8).
Those works, as Christ declared, are lies and murder (see John 8:44; Psalm 72
said "fraud and violence"). Nowhere is the alliance between lying and murdering
more clear than in the abortion industry. Women are told their child is a "blob
of tissue." They are told the abortion procedure is "safe," whereas in truth it
carries untold burdens of physical and mental anguish. The pro-abortion lies are
an echo of the original lie told to the first woman, "You certainly will not
die" (Gen. 3:4b). Nowhere besides the abortion mills are there larger numbers of
more defenseless people crying out for our intervention. A man of Christ must
intervene; a priest must "make justice his aim" (see Is. 1:17).
There is a story from the days of the Nazi atrocities that tells of a church
along a road where the trains passed, carrying Jews to execution. When they
passed the church on Sunday mornings, they would cry out in the hope that the
worshipers would hear their cries and rescue them. The noise of the wailing
prompted members of the congregation to ask the pastor, "What are we to do about
this disturbance to our worship?" The pastor paused and then said, "Tell the
people to sing a little louder." This sad temptation to avoid the distraction of
human lives in danger can surface again today for Christians who may think they
are too busy with other things to worry about the abortion issue...too busy to
worry about justice.
The Bread of Life
A priest is a man of the Eucharist, and it is in the Mass that we touch the
definitive victory of life over death. "Dying you destroyed our death, rising
you restored our life." "I am the Bread of Life" (John 6:35). The Eucharist is
the sacrifice of life and the banquet of life, and because the priest officiates
at this sacrificial banquet, he is truly "Father," imparting life to all who
come. The priest guards the Eucharist, which is both a human and a Divine Life,
for it is Christ himself. The priest leads his people to adore the Eucharist and
to see, beyond the appearances, the reality of life. This is why he must stand
powerfully in defense of human life which, in its initial stages, is also hidden
from human sight, yet no less sacred for that reason. Just as the Sacred Host is
"defenseless," so is the pre-born child. Just as the Sacred Host is sacred
because it is God, so is the pre-born child the sacred image of God. If the
priest is the defender of the sacred, then he is such wherever and whenever the
sacred is attacked. "This is my Body." These words are at the heart of
priesthood. They are also at the heart of pro-life. They are the words of
Christ. Are they not also the words of the pre-born child?
The Greatest Obstacle to Abortion
Dr. Bernard Nathanson was one of the engineers of the abortion-rights
movement in this country. He is now one of its leading spokespersons for life.
Some years ago I attended a talk he gave to priests. After recounting to us how
he and his colleagues launched the abortion industry, he looked at us and said,
"We would never have gotten away with what we did if you had been united,
purposeful, and strong."
He knew then what abortion-rights activists still know today. Their greatest
obstacle is the Church.
The Church is the only institution that has a Divine guarantee that it will
prevail over the culture of death. "The gates of hell will not prevail against
it," the Lord Himself said (Mt.16:18) When we hear these words, we usually
think, "The Church will survive all the attacks launched against her," and
certainly that is part of the meaning. Upon further reflection, however, we
realize that in a battle, a gate does not run out into the battlefield to attack
the enemy. Rather, the gate stands still and defends the city against the enemy
attacking it! When the Lord says the gates of hell will not prevail against the
Church, He means that the Church is taking the initiative and storming the
gates! Those gates of hell cannot withstand the power of heaven; gates of sin
melt in the presence of saving grace; gates of death fall in the presence of
eternal life; gates of falsehood collapse in the presence of living truth; gates
of violence fall in the presence of divine love. These are the tools with which
Christ has equipped His Church. These are the tools at our disposal as priests.
A System of Communication
With over 19,000 parishes and 9000 schools of every educational level in
the United States, the Catholic community has a unique structure through which
people can be reached with the truth regarding abortion and what they can do
about it. Progress in the pro-life effort does not so much require new
structures but rather the full activation of the structures we already have.
Preaching to the Choir
An analysis of the opinions of Americans on abortion reveals that one of
the most consistent indicators of a person's position on abortion is the
regularity of his or her Sunday worship. The more consistently one attends
Church, in any denomination, the more likely that person is to be opposed to
To some priests, this might suggest that we don't need to "preach to the
choir." This was the view expressed to me by one woman in the large parish I
served in the city of New York. She said to me one Sunday, "About all this
preaching on abortion, Father…We’re not the ones who need to hear it. It’s all
the people out there, they need to hear it!" "Well then," I told her, "Go tell
them!" We do not simply preach about abortion because our people do not know
about it, but rather because they do. The fact that they do makes them the most
likely group to do something about it. When we say "Go in peace," we are giving
them a commission, as the Lord gave the apostles, to take the grace and truth
they have received at Mass into the world which also needs it so much.
Priests are called to inspire and equip the laity to exercise their role in
the evangelization of the family, the world of business, the realm of politics,
the domain of the media, and countless other arenas. "Choirs" gather regularly
for choir practice. With a constant barrage of pro-choice propaganda all around
them, the faithful need to be constantly nourished with the Gospel of Life.
We should not hesitate, therefore, to preach to the choir. Such preaching
equips them to sing their song to the rest of the world.
A Consistent Ethic of Life
It is essential that we preach within the context of a consistent ethic
of life. Human life is sacred under each and every circumstance and at all
stages of its development. There is, unfortunately, a sense of "disconnection"
that often exists between "pro-life" issues and "social justice" concerns. Yet
they are intimately tied together; in fact, they are facets of the same thing.
Social justice is required precisely because of the dignity of human life, and
an act that deprives one of life is a tremendous social injustice.
As the late Cardinal Joseph Bernardin pointed out in his published
explanations of the consistent ethic of life, we need to understand that
progress in any area of the defense of human life promotes progress in all other
areas, while setbacks in one area slow progress on others. Nobody should feel
he/she is exempt from concern for human life across a broad spectrum of issues.
At the same time, Cardinal Bernardin made it clear that this does not mean
all issues are the same. As he said in his lecture, "A Consistent Ethic of Life:
Continuing the Dialogue," "Each of the life issues—while related to all the
others—is distinct and calls for its own specific moral analysis" (St. Louis
University, March 11, 1984). He likewise pointed out on numerous occasions that
the consistent ethic does not preclude individuals or groups from focusing on
specific issues: "Does this mean that everyone must do everything? No! There
are limits of time energy and competency. There is a shape to every individual
vocation. People must specialize, groups must focus their energies. The
consistent ethic does not deny this" (Address at Seattle University, March
Our preaching, therefore, is to reflect a delicate balance.
It is first of all to call on our people to see the sanctity of human life
from the perspective of the Gospel, a perspective that consistently
respects, honors, and defends the dignity of each human person. Such a position
not only links all life issues, but transcends and is utterly independent of
whatever patterns of linkage or separation that may be made by political
parties, platforms, and candidates. The "platform" we preach is only and
completely that of the Gospel.
Our preaching must also take account of the realities of our day. At the
present time, no act of violence claims more lives than abortion. The website of
the Alan Guttmacher Institute (a pro-choice research organization) reports that
1.37 million surgical abortions occurred in the United States in the single year
1996. That translates into 3753 per day, or one every 23 seconds. Some 99% of
these abortions have nothing to do with rape or incest, and the reasons the vast
majority of them are performed, again according to pro-choice sources, have
nothing to do with medical necessity. These abortions are performed,
furthermore, throughout all nine months of pregnancy, and are publicly
advertised in the yellow pages and on the Internet.
The Pastoral Plan for Pro-life Activities of the United States Bishops (1985
Reaffirmation) stated, "Moreover, among the many important issues involving
the dignity of human life with which the Church is concerned, abortion
necessarily plays a central role. Abortion's direct attack on innocent human
life is precisely the kind of violent act that can never be justified. Because
victims of abortion are the most vulnerable and defenseless members of the human
family, it is imperative that we, as Christians called to serve the least among
us, give urgent attention and priority to this issue of justice…. In a society
where abortion is claimed as "a woman's right," the most fundamental right—the
right to life—is denied, and the basis for defending the rights of all women and
men is, thereby, eroded. In this Pastoral Plan we, therefore, focus attention
especially on the pervasive threat to human life arising from the present
situation of abortion virtually on demand.
"This focus and the Church's firm commitment to a consistent ethic of life
complement each other. A consistent ethic, far from diminishing concern for
abortion or equating all issues touching on the dignity of human life,
recognizes the distinctive character of each issue while giving each its proper
role within a coherent moral vision."
Both Evangelium Vitae (John Paul II, 1995) and Living the Gospel of
Life (US Bishops, 1998) point out similar reasons why abortion deserves
It is important also to understand how difficult it is for our people to find
the truth about abortion. Dr. Bernard Nathanson, for example, admits how the
efforts he and his colleagues made to promote abortion consisted of lies (see
his book Aborting America). Carol Everett and many other former
abortionists admit how abortion facilities lie to women who come (see Carol's
book, Blood Money). Studies have shown the pro-abortion bias of the media
(see Michael Medved’s book Hollywood vs. America). Many politicians
refuse to address abortion because, they say, it is a "religious issue." Many
schools do not want to address it because they do not want to "impose morality"
or deal with issues that are "too controversial." And although it is the most
commonly performed surgery in America, it's hard to find someone who has
actually viewed one.
The teaching and preaching of the Church remain today one of the only avenues
through which this tragedy is likely to be addressed adequately and honestly.
Some clergy ask how often they should preach on abortion.
One way to approach this question would be to ask yourself what you would do
if a tragedy in our country were claiming the lives of 4000 two-year-old
children every day. How often would we bring it up in our preaching?
Whatever our answer, we can then consider that abortion has the same effect.
The victims are simply younger.
A Note On Liturgical Norms For Homilies
There is a concern among a significant number of Catholic clergy that it
is difficult to preach on abortion because the topic does not seem to harmonize
with the readings assigned for a given liturgy.
This concern needs to be addressed from at least two perspectives. First,
the homilist is not constrained by the readings. Second, the Scriptures do
provide countless links with the abortion issue.
A homilist is not required to limit himself to commentary on the
assigned Scripture readings. The pertinent liturgical law is found in the
General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM, which is printed at the
beginning of every Sacramentary), paragraph 41. It reads, "The homily is
strongly recommended as an integral part of the liturgy and as a necessary
source of nourishment of the Christian life. It should develop some point of the
readings or of another text from the Ordinary of the Mass of the day. The
homilist should keep in mind the mystery that is being celebrated and the needs
of the particular community." Notice that the homilist is given a choice. He can
preach on the readings or "another text" of the liturgy. These "other texts"
include the prayers of the Mass which are constant, such as the Profession of
Faith, the prayers at the Presentation Of the Gifts, the Eucharistic Prayers,
and the Our Father. They also include the "presidential prayers," which vary
In relation to abortion, the Profession of Faith has three powerful
points of departure: "We believe in one God... Maker of heaven and earth, of all
that is seen and unseen. . . We believe in One Lord, Jesus Christ... through
Him all things were made... We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord and
Giver of life."
Paragraph 41 of the GIRM also indicates that the "needs of the
particular community" are to be kept in mind in shaping the homily. Statistics
show the incidence of abortion within our own Catholic communities, and
experience demonstrates the constant stream of propaganda which our people hear
from respectable segments of society to justify abortion. It is quite clear that
the community has a paramount need to hear the truth about abortion.
When the homilist does preach more directly on the readings, he should
note that there are countless ways to bring in the abortion issue. The GIRM says
he may "develop some point of the readings." To "develop" a point indicates that
the readings are a springboard rather than a straight jacket. What is preached
does not have to be explicitly mentioned in the passages. A theme may be
suggested in any one or several of the readings. The homilist is not limited to
the Gospel. The other readings, including the psalm, provide powerful themes.
The abortion issue is right in the firing line of such basic Scriptural themes
as; 1) the dominion of God over human life, 2) justice, 3) defense of the weak
and helpless, 4) creation of man and woman in God's image and likeness, 5) the
covenant, 6) the prohibition of murder, 7) sin, 8) love of neighbor, 9) truth,
10) service, 11) Christ as the Resurrection and the Life, 12) responsibility and
solidarity, 13) God's victory over death, and many others.
Liturgy is, ultimately, a life-giving encounter with God. There can be no
more appropriate setting in which to proclaim and defend the gift of life. The
liturgical laws of the Church certainly leave the door wide open for such a
proclamation and defense!
Speaking to Children about Abortion
At the start of the homily, I asked for a volunteer from among the
youngest, smallest members of the congregation. Sharon, who was about six, came
forward. I had her stand next to me facing the people and asked her, "Sharon,
are there people out there who are bigger than you?" "Yes!" she exclaimed. "Are
there people out there who are older than you?" "Yes!" she exclaimed. "Are there
people out there who are stronger than you?" "Yes!" she exclaimed. "Are there
people out there who are more important than you?" "No!" she declared, with even
more conviction in her voice. All the other children understood the same thing.
And thus they understood the key problem in the abortion tragedy.
Abortion builds on the lie that the smallest and weakest among us have less
value and can even be discarded.
Teaching children about abortion is not as difficult as many think.
Children are particularly receptive to the message of equality of all people,
and to the truth that might does not make right. They have a keen sense of
justice and fairness. They know what it means to need protection from dangers
they can neither withstand nor understand. They know what a baby is, and they
know it is wrong to kill a baby.
Furthermore, they have not been around long enough to practice the mental
gymnastics and exercises in denial that are necessary for developing and
maintaining a pro-choice position.
It is not necessary to teach children the details of reproduction before
they learn that abortion is a bad thing. The basis for teaching about abortion
is not the reproductive system, but the dignity and worth of every human person,
whether that person is big or small, young or old, healthy or sick, wanted or
unwanted, convenient or inconvenient.
The basis for teaching young people about abortion is the same basis on
which we teach that the commandment "Thou shalt not kill" applies to any other
category of people.
Some may be afraid to use the word "abortion" with children, reasoning
that as someone once told me, "they don't understand all the aspects of it."
Let's face it -- nobody does. We do not aim to teach them "all the aspects." The
key point with children is that when they hear the word "abortion," they know it
is something bad, something that kills, something to be avoided. Education is
not just concepts. We influence children not only in how they think about
abortion, but in how they feel about it. They should be trained to reject it,
and to see it as a part of the list of injustices and evils in the world rather
than part of the list of rights, freedoms, and choices. The Pontifical Council
for the Family has written, "Before adolescence, the immoral nature of abortion,
surgical or chemical, can be gradually explained in terms of Catholic morality
and reverence for human life" (1995: The Truth and Meaning of Human Sexuality,
Some express a concern that children will be traumatized if we tell them
that abortion kills babies. I once sat in on a staff meeting at which a proposal
was made to set up a sign on parish property that said, "Abortion Kills
Children." The staff voted down the proposal on the basis that it would give
nightmares to the school children who would see it. A few days later I was in
that same school, and in the corridor of the first and second grade students I
saw posters on the wall, made by the students themselves. The posters had
skeletons coming up from the grave, people falling off an abyss, and various
other nightmare scenes, with the message: "DRUGS KILL." "SAYING YES TO DRUGS IS
LIKE SAYING YES TO MR. DEATH."
Isn't it curious how selective we can sometimes be about which messages we
think will frighten our children…
The pro-life message will not harm our children. What will harm them,
however, is the "pro-choice" mentality, which will train them to think that
human life is a disposable item, and which, if unchallenged, may lead them to an
abortion mill someday.
The Partnership for a Drug-Free America has a television commercial which
says, "The perfect time to talk to your child about using marijuana is when you
think he's too young to talk about using marijuana. Talk to your child before
someone else does." Abortion is a clear parallel. To a parent who once objected
to my pro-life preaching because her children were present, I gently pointed out
to them that I share her concern for her children’s welfare. I then told her
that it is better that they hear about abortion from me, in the presence of
their parents who can discuss their questions and calm their fears, than if they
hear about abortion from pro-choice people who will tell them the false and
dangerous lie that abortion is "no big deal." Worse yet, of course, is if the
first time they hear anything substantial about abortion is from the "counselor"
who is trying to sell them one.
Parents are the primary educators of their children. This requires that
priests and other educators cooperate closely with them. It does not mean,
however, that either the parents or other educators have the right to keep their
children from the truth. In one instance when I spoke to seventh graders about
how abortion harms women, one set of parents objected because I had not received
their permission to bring up the topic in class. I assured them that I had no
intention of bypassing their parental authority and that, in fact, I welcomed
their input. I pointed out that people differ in their judgment of which matters
require special parental approval and which do not. I then invited them to be at
least equally upset over the fact that their daughter can actually obtain an
abortion and be harmed by it without their knowledge or consent, as they were
upset that their daughter had heard about abortion and its harmful effects
without their knowledge or consent. Public health records in New York State have
shown as many as 231 abortions on thirteen-year-old girls in one year.
I know of another case in which parental permission was obtained for all
the students in the class, except one, to see a photo of an aborted baby. After
school the student whose parents had denied permission insisted that her friend
let her see the picture. On returning home she passionately challenged her mom,
"Why did you not want me to see what is really happening to these babies! Why
was I not allowed to see the truth?"
It is particularly appropriate that children share our concern about
abortion. After all, they are closer in age to those who are being killed.
Furthermore, they were considered "non-persons" before the law during the first
nine months of their existence! If I were born after the Roe vs. Wade decision,
I would take that as a personal insult! What loss today's children have
sustained from abortion! Those aborted would have been their classmates, their
friends, their husbands and wives! Psychological research is being done on the
impact of this tragedy on those whose lives might have been taken, had they not
been "wanted." The International Institute for Pregnancy Loss and Child Abuse
Research and Recovery has identified ten types of "abortion survivors" and has
published evidence of how damaging it is for a child to grow up in a society in
which he/she could have been aborted.
I once spoke at a cemetery service at a grave containing the aborted
bodies of several hundred babies. At the end of the service, each person present
placed a rose on the grave and departed. Most people missed the scene at the
very end. A very young girl, just able to walk, took a rose to the grave by;
herself and placed it there. She was, indeed, closest to her brothers and
sisters in that grave. The youngest had compassion on her peers, who might have
seen the sun that day as she did.
I have often seen the truth in the words of the Second Vatican Council,
"Children too have an apostolate of their own. In their own measure they are
true living witnesses of Christ among their companions" (Decree on the
Apostolate of Lay People, #12). They will respond actively to the pro-life
message, as did the two who wrote me and said, "Hi, I'd like to begin this
letter by thanking you for last week's homily. I was deeply moved and so was my
younger brother. Although we are both young, I'm 17 and he's 12, we've been
taught how precious life is. But we did not fully understand what goes on in
abortion till your homily…We both want to get on the mailing lists of pro-life
Children particularly like to wear the Precious Feet pin, showing the
exact size and shape of a baby's feet at 10 weeks after conception. It was a
child's idea to put those feet on top of pink and blue ribbons. A major pro-life
organization then made the combination into a pin!
I once met a 7-year old named Nick among a group of young people peacefully
demonstrating outside an abortion mill. "This must be your first time taking
part in something like this," I said to him. "O no, Father," he exclaimed. "I've
protested abortion in New York, Chicago, Atlanta, and other places…"
A group of summer campers I once served, ages 8 to 10, sent a joint
letter to the local paper to speak up for preborn children.
These and many other projects can be organized in parishes and schools,
or as part of Confirmation service projects. Preaching and teaching will lead
even the young to action. Silence will only allow the killing to continue.
The following moving letter was written by a fourth-grade girl.
I was so excited about what my life in this world would be. I thought
about all the things I would like to do like playing with toys, riding a bike,
going to the zoo, and having a dog. I wanted to see movies, go to school, make
friends and go to the park and the circus. I wanted to celebrate Christmas and
receive Jesus in Holy Communion. I looked forward to listening to music,
dancing, swimming in a pool, playing soccer, and having dolls.
I am very sad that I never got to do any of these things. My mother did
not let me be born. I just don't understand one thing. Why didn't any of you
help me? I wish you had. No one heard my crying voice.
An unborn baby"
"Let the children come to me," the Lord declares. Let them come to His
Church; let them come to us, that we may love them and teach them the dignity
and greatness of all human life
Are You Too Old to Save a Life?
People beyond childbearing age may tell us, "Abortion is not my problem--I’m
too old for that!"
While such people may be too old to have a child, they are never too old
to love one, never too old to save one. They are therefore never too old to be
concerned about abortion. By our active concern, any one of us can save the life
of a baby scheduled to die. To try to save our youngest brothers and sisters is
an expression of the love we are bound to for all our lives.
Parents and grandparents, furthermore, have a crucial, sometimes decisive
role in the attitudes of their children and grandchildren toward abortion. Do
they pass on a concern for life? Do they convey compassion, so that if their
daughter or granddaughter were to become pregnant, she would know she could turn
to them for understanding, rather than turn to the abortionist?
Despite age, people can continue to make their voices heard in arenas of
public opinion and the political process.
Let nobody say they are too old to be concerned about abortion. As long
as we possess life, we have the duty to defend life.
Concrete "Points of Entry" into the Topic of Abortion
There are many "points of entry" into the abortion issue. One may speak
directly of the child as the least among us, and of his/her rights and our
responsibilities to him/her. One may, on the other hand, begin by speaking about
the rights of the woman to better choices than abortion, and the many ways that
abortion hurts women. (Priests for Life offers a packet of information on this
topic.) Abortion can also be addressed in the context of justice and peace, and
the need to reject violence and promote the unity of the human family. The point
of entry can also be God Himself as the source of life and the Giver of the
right to life. These and many other starting points, Biblical and
extra-Biblical, offer a speaker enough options to adapt a homily or talk to many
diverse needs and situations.
Sometimes an entire homily should be devoted to the abortion tragedy. At
other times, one can simply make reference to abortion when speaking, for
example, of the evils in the world or the requirements of loving our neighbor.
It may mean just the mention of the word, or perhaps a sentence or two. The
Golden Rule, for example, provides a short, effective argument against abortion.
Just let people put themselves in the baby’s place. (We were, in fact, there at
one time.) Other Scriptural references are given below.
Scriptural Starting Points
The Bible clearly teaches that abortion is wrong. This teaching comes across
in many ways and for many reasons. Some people point out that the word
"abortion" is not in the Bible, and that is true. Nevertheless, the teaching
about abortion is there. This is the case with many teachings. The word
"Trinity" is not in the Bible, but the teaching about the Trinity is there. In
any case, a person who wants to deny the teaching about abortion would deny it
even if the word were there.
Let’s look at some of the Biblical reasons why abortion, the deliberate
destruction of a child in the womb, is very wrong.
1. God has absolute dominion over human life.
This theme is reflected in the creation accounts and in all the Scriptural
passages declaring God to be Lord of the universe. Because God has made us, our
lives and bodies are not our own, nor are our choices absolute. "None of us
lives as his own master and none of us dies as his own master. While we live we
are responsible to the Lord, and when we die we die as his servants"
(Rom.14:7-8). "You are not your own. You have been purchased, and at a price"
The Bible teaches that human life is different from other types of
life, because human beings are made in the very image of God.
The accounts of the creation of man and woman in Genesis (Genesis 1:26-31;
2:4-25) tell us this: "God created man in his image; in the divine image he
created him; male and female he created them" (Genesis 1:27).
The word "create" is used three times here, emphasizing a special crowning
moment in the whole process of God’s making the world and everything in it. The
man and woman are given "dominion" over everything else in the visible world.
Not even the original sin takes away the image of God in human beings. St.
James refers to this image and says that because of it we should not even speak
ill of one another. "With [the tongue] we bless the Lord and Father, and with it
we curse human beings who are made in the image of God . . . This ought not be
so, brothers" (James 3:9-10).
The image of God! This is what it means to be human! We are not just a bunch
of cells randomly thrown together by some impersonal forces. Rather, we really
reflect an eternal God who knew us from before we were made, and purposely
called us into being.
At the heart of the abortion tragedy is the question raised in the Psalms:
"Lord, what is man that you care for him, mortal man that you keep him in mind?
. . . With glory and honor you crowned him, giving him power over the works of
your hands" (Psalm 8:5-7).
There is the key. Not only did God make us, but He values us. The Bible tells
us of a God who is madly in love with us, so much so that He became one of us
and even died for us while we were still offending Him (see Romans 5:6-8).
All of this clearly contradicts the statement abortion makes, that is, that
human life is disposable.
3. The Bible teaches that children are a blessing.
God commanded our first parents to "Be fertile and multiply" (Genesis 1:28).
Why? God Himself is fertile. Love always overflows into life. When the first
mother brought forth the first child, she exclaimed, "I have brought forth a man
with the help of the Lord" (Genesis 4:1). The help of the Lord is essential, for
He has dominion over human life and is its origin. Parents cooperate with God in
bringing forth life. Because this whole process is under God’s dominion, it is
sinful to interrupt it. The prophet Amos condemns the Ammonites "because they
ripped open expectant mothers in Gilead" (Amos 1:13).
"Truly children are a gift from the Lord; the fruit of the womb is a reward"
4. The Bible teaches that the child in the womb is truly a human child,
who even has a relationship with the Lord.
The phrase "conceived and bore" is used repeatedly (see Genesis 4:1,17) and
the individual has the same identity before as after birth. "In sin my mother
conceived me," the repentant psalmist says in Psalm 51:7. The same word is used
for the child before and after birth (Brephos, that is, "infant," is used in
Luke 1:41 and Luke 18:15.)
God knows the preborn child. "You knit me in my mother’s womb . . . nor was
my frame unknown to you when I was made in secret" (Psalm 139:13,15). God also
helps and calls the preborn child. "You have been my guide since I was first
formed . . . from my mother’s womb you are my God" (Psalm 22:11-12). "God… from
my mother’s womb had set me apart and called me through his grace" (St. Paul to
the Galatians 1:15).
5. Scripture repeatedly condemns the killing of the innocent.
This flows from everything that has been seen so far. God’s own finger writes
in stone the commandment "Thou shalt not kill" (Exodus 20:13, Deuteronomy 5:17)
and Christ reaffirms it (Matthew 19:18 - notice that He mentions this
commandment first). The Book of Revelation affirms that (unrepentant) murderers
cannot enter the kingdom of heaven (Revelation 22:15).
The killing of children is especially condemned by God through the prophets.
In the land God gave his people to occupy, foreign nations had the custom of
sacrificing some of their children in fire. God told His people that they were
not to share in this sin. They did, however, as Psalm 106 relates: "They mingled
with the nations and learned their works…They sacrificed their sons and their
daughters to demons, and they shed innocent blood, the blood of their sons and
their daughters, whom they sacrificed to the idols of Canaan, desecrating the
land with bloodshed" (Psalm 106:35, 37-38).
This sin of child-sacrifice, in fact, is mentioned as one of the major
reasons that the Kingdom of Israel was destroyed by the Assyrians and the people
taken into exile. "They mutilated their sons and daughters by fire…till the
Lord, in his great anger against Israel, put them away out of his sight" (2
Notice that this practice was a religious ritual. Not even for "religious
freedom" can the killing of children be tolerated.
6. The Bible teaches that God is a God of justice.
An act of justice is an act of intervention for the helpless, an act of
defense for those who are too weak to defend themselves. In foretelling the
Messiah, Psalm 72 says, "Justice shall flower in his days…for he shall rescue
the poor man when he cries out and the afflicted when he has no one to help him"
(Psalms 72:7,12). Jesus Christ is our justice (1 Corinthians 1:30) because He
rescued us from sin and death when we had none to help us (see Romans 5:6,
If God does justice for His people, He expects His people to do justice for
one another. "Be merciful as your heavenly Father is merciful" (Luke 6:36). "Go
and do likewise" (Luke 10:37). "Do unto others as you would have them do to you"
(Matthew 7:12). "Love one another" (John 15:17).
Abortion is the opposite of these teachings. It is a reversal of justice. It
is a destruction of the helpless rather than a rescue of them. If God’s people
do not intervene to save those whose lives are attacked, then the people are not
pleasing or worshiping Him.
God says through Isaiah, "Trample my courts no more! Bring no more worthless
offerings…Your festivals I detest…When you spread out your hands, I close my
eyes to you; though you pray the more, I will not listen. Your hands are full of
blood! Wash yourselves clean…learn to do good. Make justice your aim: redress
the wronged, hear the orphan’s plea, defend the widow" (Isaiah 1:13-17).
Indeed, those who worship God but promote abortion are falling into the same
contradiction as God’s people of old, and need to hear the same message.
7. Jesus Christ paid special attention to the poor, the despised, and
those whom the rest of society considered insignificant.
He broke down the false barriers that people set up among themselves, and
instead acknowledged the equal human dignity of every individual, despite what
common opinion might say. Hence we see Him reach out to children despite the
efforts of the apostles to keep them away (Matthew 19:13-15); to tax collectors
and sinners despite the objections of the Scribes (Mark 2:16); to the blind
despite the warnings of the crowd (Matthew 20:29-34); to a foreign woman despite
the utter surprise of the disciples and of the woman herself (John 4:9, 27); to
Gentiles despite the anger of the Jews (Matthew 21:41-46); and to the lepers,
despite their isolation from the rest of society (Luke 17:11-19).
When it comes to human dignity, Christ erases distinctions. St. Paul
declares, "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave or free
person, there is not male and female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus"
We can likewise say, "There is neither born nor unborn." Using this
distinction as a basis for the value of life or the protection one deserves is
meaningless and offensive to all that Scripture teaches. The unborn are the
segment of our society which is most neglected and discriminated against. Christ
Himself surely has a special love for them.
8. Scripture teaches us to love.
St. John says, "This is the message you have heard from the beginning: we
should love one another, unlike Cain who belonged to the evil one and
slaughtered his brother" (1 John 3:11-12). Love is directly contrasted with
slaughter. To take the life of another is to break the command of love. To fail
to help those in need and danger is also to fail to love.
Christ teaches this clearly in the parable of the Good Samaritan (Luke
10:25-37), in the story of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31), and in many
No group of people is in more serious danger than the boys and girls in the
womb. "If someone…sees a brother in need and refuses him compassion, how can the
love of God remain in Him?" (1 John 3:17). Love, then, is what fuels the
pro-life movement, impelling us to save the lives of children and provide
life-giving alternatives to their parents. Love likewise demands that we reach
out with compassion and healing to all wounded by abortion. If the pro-life
movement is not a movement of love, it is nothing; but if it is a movement of
love, nothing can stop it, for "Love is more powerful than death" (Song of Songs
Abortion, in short, is the opposite of love. Love means, "I sacrifice myself
for the good of the other person." Abortion means, "I sacrifice the other person
for the good of myself."
9. Life is victorious over death.
This is one of Scripture’s most basic themes. The victory of life is foretold
in the promise that the head of the serpent, through whom death entered the
world, would be crushed (see Genesis 3:15).
Isaiah promised, "He will destroy death forever" (Isaiah 25:8). At the scene
of the first murder, the soil "opened its mouth" to swallow Abel’s blood. At the
scene of the final victory of life, it is death itself that "will be swallowed
up in victory. Where, O death, is your victory? Where, O death, is your
sting?…Thanks be to God who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ"
(1 Corinthians 15:54-57).
Abortion is death. Christ came to conquer death, and therefore abortion. "I
have come that they may have life, and have it to the full" (John 10:10).
The final outcome of the battle for life has already been decided by the
Resurrection of Christ. We are not just working for victory; we are working from
victory. We joyfully take a victory that has already been won, and proclaim,
celebrate, and serve it until He comes again to bring it to its fullness. "There
shall be no more death" (Revelation 21:4). "Amen. Come, Lord Jesus!" (Revelation
Expanding upon Some Specific Passages
1. Gen. 4:8-16 Am I my Brother's Keeper?
"Let us go out into the field," Cain said to his younger brother Abel. When
they were in the field, Cain killed Abel (Gen. 4:8). The Lord then asked Cain,
"Where is your brother?" This was the most uncomfortable question Cain had yet
faced in his life. How could he stand up to God and explain the murder of his
own brother? It was an issue he wished would go away; it was a truth too hard to
deal with. So, in a desperate attempt to dodge the issue, he claimed ignorance.
"I do not know," was his response to God.
It is interesting to note that the United States Supreme Court, in its 1973
abortion decision Roe vs. Wade, faced the same question and gave the same
answer. "Where is your brother?" The Court responded, "We need not resolve the
difficult question of when life begins. When those trained in the respective
disciplines of medicine, philosophy, and theology are unable to arrive at any
consensus, the judiciary, at this point in the development of man's knowledge,
is not in a position to speculate as to the answer." [410 U.S. 113, 159] In
other words, "I don't know."
Then Cain went on to challenge God for asking the question in the first
place. "Am I my brother's keeper?" (Gen. 4:9) With these words, he tried to
absolve himself of responsibility for his brother. Abel's whereabouts, his
safety, his very life were not the responsibility of Cain! This response is
mirrored today by those who claim they are just "minding their own business"
rather than getting involved in the effort to end abortion.
God, however, called Cain back at once to take responsibility for his own
actions against his brother. "What have you done?", God demanded. Cain wanted
the issue to go away, but it wouldn't go away. The issue was as close to Cain as
Cain himself. It was his own action that took his brother's life. Yes, he is his
brother's keeper by the very fact that he is his brother. His brother has rights
which he must "keep;" that is, respect and, if necessary, defend. Cain had done
the opposite. He held his brother's rights in contempt. He had no regard for his
brother's very right to life. He tried to conceal his action by taking his
brother into the field, where nobody else would see them. Yet God confirms that
the deed cannot be covered over. "Listen," God tells Cain, "Your brother's blood
cries out to me from the soil!" (Gen. 4:10) The issue just won't go away.
We are our brothers' keepers; this is not an option. Rather, it flows
from our very existence as sons and daughters of one God in one human family. We
do not only have responsibilities toward those we choose. Rather, we have
responsibilities towards one another even before we choose. We have
responsibility especially for the weakest and most defenseless ones in our
society, the unborn, who are daily ripped apart in their mothers' womb by
Our Lord Jesus Christ is ultimately the one who answers Cain's argument,
"Am I my brother's keeper?" and our arguments about "minding our business" and
about "privacy." Christ is the one who teaches us in clear terms that we do have
responsibility to each other, and that we cannot make the issue of injustice to
our neighbor go away. For Christ declares to us, "Love one another as I have
loved you" (John 15:12). How did he love us? St. Paul tells us, "It is precisely
in this that God shows his love for us: that while we were still sinners, Christ
died for us" (Romans 5:8). In other words, Christ took the initiative. He came
to us and died for us before our asking him and without our deserving him. We
were totally helpless. He acted out of pure love when he saw our need. He made
our plight his business. He didn't hesitate for one minute; he didn't ask His
Father, "Am I my brother's keeper?"
As Christ loved us, so must we love our pre-born brothers and sisters. We
do not love them because they ask it or merit it. We love them because they are
our brothers and sisters in need. Abortion is an issue that is solved not by
wishing it away or ignoring it. It is solved only by active love. We are our
brother's keeper. Amen!
2. Ex.20:16 Abortion and the Eighth Commandment
We usually think of abortion as a violation of the Fifth Commandment, "Thou
shalt not kill," and that is true. But abortion is wrong for many reasons. It
breaks all the commandments.
The Eighth Commandment says, "Thou shalt not bear false witness against
thy neighbor." This is not only a matter of falsely testifying that somebody did
something wrong, as we see, for example, in the Old Testament story of Susanna
(Daniel 13). This commandment also forbids false testimony about who our
neighbor is, about what value and dignity our neighbor possesses, and about what
our obligations to our neighbor are.
The question in abortion is not only, "When does life begin?" but more
deeply, "What does life mean?" What are the implications of being human? Is
human life disposable when it is unwanted, or inconvenient, or not recognized by
a government? Is there anything about human existence that cries out for
recognition and protection apart from what a particular society decides to
bestow? What is the truth about humanity? What is the human person destined for?
Are we made for the grave or for the skies?
Abortion not only takes a life; it makes a statement about life, and not
only about the life it takes, but about the lives of all of us. Abortion says we
are disposable. Abortion says our value is determined by others. Abortion says
there is no intrinsic dignity in human life that requires its absolute
protection, and no destiny that reaches beyond this world or even beyond this
Do not bear false witness against your neighbor! Abortion lies about the
human person. Christ, on the other hand, reveals the truth about human life (see
Vatican II, Constitution on the Church in the Modern World #22.)
Particularly by His Ascension, He shows that we are made for the heights of
heaven, not for the medical waste bag.
"Lord, what is man that You care for him?" (Ps.8:5). The psalmist asked
the question, and God Himself answered it in Christ. May our treatment of human
life faithfully echo that answer!
3. Mt.7:12 The Golden Rule
When we come close to Christ, He makes it very clear how we are to respond to
our neighbor. These, in fact, are the first two Commandments of Christ's Law:
love God above all; love your neighbor as yourself. Two sayings of our Lord make
it clear how we must love our neighbor. One is the Golden Rule: "Do unto others
as you would have them do unto you." The other is, "Whatsoever you do to the
least of my brothers, you do to Me."
These words of Christ help us deal with one of the most burning issues of our
day: abortion. Our response to abortion is a response to a tiny, helpless child
and his/her mother. Apply the Golden Rule. Put yourself in the child’s place.
(We were all in the womb at one point ourselves.) Would you want to be cared for
and nourished and brought safely to birth, or aborted? How easily the child is
forgotten, because he/she is not seen and cannot protest the abortion decision.
But who would want to be killed in his/her mother's womb? The Golden Rule also
applies to the mother. If you were afraid because you felt you could not handle
a pregnancy, what would you want? Help! We need to commit ourselves to help
mothers raise their children, not kill them. There are over 3,000 helping
centers throughout the country, but they need more assistance from all of us!
Our Lord also tells us, "Whatsoever you do to the least of my brothers,
you do to me." After we put ourselves in the position of the pre-born child and
the mother, we then put Christ Himself there! Surely the pre-born child is the
"least" of His brothers and sisters! The preborn have the least power, the least
protection, the least voice! They cannot speak, vote, protest, or even pray! The
mothers also are often so alone, and cast aside by those who don't understand
their problems. Christ makes it clear: by helping both mother and child, we are
helping Him! By rejecting the mother and child, we reject Him!
To love one another as Christ taught us demands that we reject abortion
completely, and work for better, life-giving choices! Amen!
4. Lk.16:19-31 The Lazarus of the 20th Century
We learn many lessons from those who go to heaven. In the story of the Rich
Man and Lazarus, we learn a lesson from one who went to hell.
Why was the Rich Man condemned? Was it because he had so much? Was there
something inherently sinful about the purple and linen in which he dressed, or
the feasts in which he indulged? No. The rich man went to hell because he
ignored the other man. He was not condemned for what he did, but for what he did
not do. He did not recognize or treat Larzarus as his equal, his brother.
Instead, he thought that because Lazarus' possessions were less valuable than
his, that Lazarus was less valuable than he. The beggar's cries went unheeded.
The story causes us to wonder what we would do if we were there. Brothers
and sisters, we are there. You and I have an appointment with Lazarus today, and
we will be judged on how we respond. The Lazarus of the 20th century is in our
midst. He is in our midst in the poor, the troublesome, the annoying, the person
who is smaller and weaker than we are, and the person who seems different and
In particular, the Lazarus of the 20th century is our preborn brother or
sister. This is the person rejected by society, the person who begs for help to
live but whose cries are rejected 4400 times a day in our country. This is the
person torn apart and thrown away by abortion.
The rich man was condemned for not treating Lazarus as his brother. We
also will be condemned if we do not treat the preborn as our brother or sister.
Many oppose abortion and would never have one, but they then ask, "Who am I to
interfere with a woman's choice to abort?" Today, I will tell you who you are.
You are a brother, a sister of that child in the womb! "Who am I to interfere
with her choice?" You are a human being who has enough decency to stand up and
say "NO!" when you see another human being about to be killed. "Who am I to
interfere with her choice?" You are a person who has enough wisdom to realize
that injustice to one human being is injustice to every human being, and that
your life is only as safe as the life of the preborn child. "Who am I to
interfere with her choice?" You are a follower of the One who said, "Whatsoever
you do to the least of my brothers, you do to Me." Do we not believe that if we
allow a person to die of starvation, that we are allowing Christ to die of
starvation? Do we not believe that if we leave the sick untended, that we are
leaving Christ untended? Must we not then also believe that whenever a child in
the womb is ripped apart, burned, crushed, and then thrown away, that Christ is
ripped apart, burned, crushed, and thrown away? It is Christ in the womb! When
we stand up for life we stand up for Him!
If abortion is not wrong then nothing is wrong. If we cannot be stirred
to respond as individuals, as a Church, and as a nation, to the plight of the
preborn children, then we have lost our soul. Indeed, the Lazarus of the 20th
century is knocking at our door. God, have mercy on us and help us to respond!
5. Jn.14:6 The Way, the Truth, and the Life
Christ Undoes Satan’s Works
There are many ways to express the purpose of Christ’s mission in the world.
St. John in his first letter sums it up by saying, "The reason the Son of God
appeared was to destroy the works of the devil" (I John 3:8). What "works of the
devil" does Christ destroy? Christ Himself tells us that the devil "was a
murderer from the beginning and does not stand in truth, because there is no
truth in him. When he tells a lie, he speaks in character, because he is a liar
and the father of lies" (John 8:44). In one and the same breath, Our Lord calls
the devil a liar and a murderer. Lies and murder go together. The only way
abortion can continue on such a horrible scale is for it to be covered in lies,
sugarcoated with denials and distortions of truth. Christ has come to destroy
the works of the devil. "I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life" (John 14:6). He
is the way to salvation precisely because He is the Truth, shattering the
devil’s lies, and because He is the Life, undoing the devil’s work of death.
A Liar and Murderer From the Beginning
We see the devil act in in character with lies and murder from the first
pages of the Bible. Adam and Eve had been told they could eat of any tree in the
garden except "the tree of the knowledge of good and evil." "In the day that you
eat of it," God warned them, "you shall die" (Gen 2:17). What is wrong with
knowing good from evil? Aren’t we supposed to know the difference between good
and evil? Isn’t that part of our religious and moral education? Don’t so many
problems come about when people do not know good from evil? Why, then, is this
the one tree of which our first parents were not to eat?
The answer lies in the fact that the "knowledge of good and evil" here does
not simply mean "knowing." It means that Adam and Eve would think they could
decide the difference between good and evil, that they would be the ones to
determine what was right and wrong, that they would be the norm of morality.
This is the original temptation. "What’s right and wrong for me is up to me...
What’s right and wrong for you is up to you... Do not impose your morality on
me. . . I will create my own values... I am accountable to nobody but myself."
In other words, it’s all up to my own personal choice. The original sin is to
put choice above goodness and truth, to abuse freedom by trying to create what
is right rather than submit to it. In his encyclical Veritatis Splendor
(The Splendor of Truth, August 6, 1993), Pope John Paul II comments on
Genesis 2:16-17. "With this image, revelation teaches that the power to decide
what is good and what is evil does not belong to man, but to God alone. The man
is certainly free... But his freedom is not unlimited: It must halt before the
‘tree of the knowledge of good and evil,’ for it is called to accept the moral
law given by God" (VS #35).
By rebelling against the truth of the moral law, we die. God had warned Adam
and Eve they would die if they disobeyed. The devil had to lie to them to
introduce death into the world. So the original liar approached the original
woman and offered the original lie: "You certainly will not die. For God knows
that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God,
knowing good and evil" (Gen. 3:4-5). Eve bought the lie, as did Adam, and they
committed the original sin. Death then entered the world, on the heels of a lie.
Babel: The Lie Continues
The original lie continued at the tower of Babel, in Babylon. It is
noteworthy that "bab-ili" means "gate of the gods." Here again, humans tried to
exalt themselves to the status of God. "Come, let us build ourselves a city, and
a tower with its top in the heavens, and let us make a name for ourselves" (Gen.
11:4). "Let us make," they said, forgetting that God is the one who said, "Let
us make man" (Gen. 1:26).
Seeing their forgetfulness and pride, God said, "This is only the beginning
of what they will do; and nothing that they propose to do will now be impossible
for them" (Gen. 11:6). God was not saying here that He felt threatened. He was
saying that people who have bought the lie that they themselves are the norm of
truth and goodness will think they can do anything, and in trying to do so, will
only destroy themselves. The original lie perpetuated will only perpetuate
death. It is His infinite mercy and love that move Him to say, "Come, let us go
down, and there confuse their language, that they may not understand one
another’s speech" (Gen. 11:17). Better for them to be scattered by God’s
intervention than dashed on the rocks of their own pride! God confused the
language only after the people had confused it first by speaking the lie that
they could make a name for themselves, rather than submitting to the name (the
truth) of God.
Babel Revisited in 1992
This lie continues in our day and, in fact, has become the official policy of
America, according to the Supreme Court. In this decision on abortion, in which
the error of Roe v. Wade was upheld, the Court stated, "At the heart of liberty
is the right to define one’s own concept of existence, of meaning, of the
universe, and of the mystery of human life." (Planned Parenthood v. Casey,
1992, [505 U.S.833, 851]) This line is incredible! We cannot even decide the
weather, and yet we are expected to define existence itself! We live in a
universe we did not create, and yet we are declared to be the creators of that
universe’s meaning! We did not call ourselves into life, yet we have the liberty
to define the meaning of life! Not only is this absurd, but it is frightfully
familiar: "You shall be like God, knowing good and evil." "Let us make a name
for ourselves." "The gate of the gods." Perhaps the Court’s decision should be
re-named "Eden and Babel Revisited."
Abortion Cloaked in Lies
The original lie leads to the ongoing slaughter of babies by abortion. The
mother is told, "It’s your choice. It’s your freedom. It’s your body. Nobody can
impose their morality on you." It is the lie that choice prevails over life
Abortion continues thanks to many other lies as well. Women are lied to about
the nature of the developing baby and about the effects of the abortion
procedure. Carol Everett, herself a victim of abortion and once an abortion
provider, wrote, "Like many others, I bought the big lie: 'It is only a glob of
tissue not a baby.' I was a victim of all the other lies: Abortion is all right.
After all, I do them all the time. It will be so simple. It’s only a glob of
tissue. There’s really nothing to the procedure; it will only take a little
while and then everything will be fine. You can have the abortion on Friday
morning and be back to work on Monday." (The Scarlet Lady, p.101 ). The
workers at the abortion center were trained to give as little information as
possible, so that women would not know the truth.
The Elliot Institute in Springfield, Illinois, does research on the effects
of abortion on women, and collects case studies in which women describe what led
them to abortion and what consequences followed. Case after case shows how they
were victimized by lies and half-truths. The efforts made to initiate
wide-spread abortion in America were marked by lies, as Dr. Bernard Nathanson,
former abortionist and co-founder of the National Abortion Rights Action League,
readily admits. Now a strong advocate for the right to life, he writes, "How
many deaths were we talking about when abortion was illegal?... It was always
‘5,000 to 10,000 a year.’ I confess that I knew the figures were totally false"
(Aborting America, p.193). A growing number of former abortion providers
in our country are coming forward to tell how they lied to women before
abortions and covered up the tracks of botched abortions by falsifying medical
The lies continue and murder continues.
The Splendor of Truth
The solution demands that we lift high the truth. Truth is on the side of
life. Truth and life go together. Let us proclaim the truth that the preborn
child is a human person from the moment of conception; that love for the woman
demands love for her child; that there are concrete, lifegiving alternatives to
abortion; that there are negative physical, psychological, and spiritual
consequences of abortion; that choice never takes priority over life itself; and
that freedom is found by submitting to the moral truth that comes from God
rather than by trying to be God ourselves. Our Holy Father has provided the
Church and the world with the bedrock foundation of moral sanity and salvation
in documents such as The Splendor of Truth and The Gospel of Life. Christ
provides us the only way of salvation namely, Himself, for He is truth and life.
Ultimately we save the world from the bondage of abortion and every other sin
by lifting Christ high. "If you continue in my Word, you are truly My disciples,
and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free" (John 8:31-32).
6. 1 Jn.4:7-10; Jn. 15:9-17 Love Leads to Life
The basis of Christianity is the Resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.
Christians rejoice in the Resurrection, because it is the victory of life not
only for Christ but for each person who believes in Him. Christ's rising from
the grave means that we too will rise from the grave!
The victory of life is also the victory of love. From the first page of
Scripture to the last, it is clear that love leads to life. These two realities
cannot be separated, because they are rooted in the one God, who cannot be
divided. Scripture tells us that God is love (1Jn. 4:8). Scripture also tells us
that God is life (see Jn.14:6). Love and life always go together.
We see this in creation. Where were you 100 years ago today? You were
nowhere; you did not exist. So why are you here today? How were you rescued from
that nothingness you were once in? Certainly you did not ask to be born. You
weren't there to do the asking. Certainly you did not earn it because you
weren't there to do anything that could earn it. What accounts for the fact that
you are here? We can say that your parents came together and you were conceived
and born, and that is true. But that doesn't fully answer the question of why
you are here. When your parents came together, there could have been millions of
possible people conceived and born, who would have been your brothers or
sisters. It didn't have to be you!
The only ultimate explanation of why you are here is that God loves you.
He chose you to be! In fact, at each moment He is literally loving you into
existence. If He stopped loving you for one instant, you would fall back into
the nothingness you were in 100 years ago. Love leads to life.
This is clear also in the mystery of salvation. St. John tells us, "This
is how God showed his love among us: He sent his only Son into the world that we
might have life through him" (1Jn 4:9). Christ's love for us brought Him to the
cross, and this led to the victory of life. The crucifix is the best symbol of
love. Love is self-giving for the good of another person. Christ gives His life
for us, without complaining and without counting the cost. His concern is that
we might have life.
Having shown His love for us in this way, He instructs us, "Love one
another as I have loved you" (Jn. 15:12). He does not say, "Love one another in
whatever way you want," but rather, "as I have loved you." We are called to love
in a way that brings forth new life. We are called to give ourselves, without
counting the cost, that others may live.
Parents, therefore, cooperate with the work of God when their love for
each other becomes a new human being. The child they bear belongs to God first.
Only God can create. Mother and father are participating in the work of God.
Parents do not own their children; God does. In fact, parents do not own
themselves. Many people today say, "This is my life, my body,
my choice." But we are not our own masters. We belong to God."Nobody lives
as his own master and nobody dies as his own master" (Rom.14:7). "You are not
your own" (1Cor. 6:19).
The choice to be a mother or father is not merely a human choice. It is
God's choice first. Our Lord tells us, "It is not you who have chosen Me. I have
chosen you, to go forth and bear fruit" (Jn.15:16). A parent becomes a parent
before s/he knows it. One is a father or mother as soon as his/her child begins
to exist, and the child begins to exist at the moment of conception. (This is
not a matter of opinion or religious belief, but a matter of verifiable and
established scientific fact.) Parents discover that they have become parents
several weeks after the fact. A pregnant woman should not say, "I'm expecting a
child." The child already exists. Nor should she say, "I'm going to be a
mother." She already is. And the man is already a father.
There is nothing comparable to having a child. Everything that a person
owns is less valuable than himself. Even if someone owns a multimillion dollar
corporation, all that money is ultimately a pile of rocks. Even gold will
eventually fade away into nothing. But a child, given an immortal soul and the
call to eternal life, will never go out of existence. For all eternity, as long
as God is God, the child, the person, will always exist. A child is equal to
his/her parents. He is not equal in age, nor in knowledge (thought he often
thinks so), nor in experience, but the child IS equal in dignity, in value, in
worth as a person created in God's image and redeemed by Christ. Every person is
equal in this way, whether in the womb or outside the womb, no matter how young
or old, healthy or sick, big or small, famous or obscure. Were one to take all
of the galaxies in the universe, with their hundreds of billions of stars and
incalculable beauty and power, they would not add up to a fraction of a fraction
of a fraction of the worth of one, tiny human child.
A parent is called to love his/her children as Christ has loved us.
"Greater love than this no one has, than to lay down his life for his friends"
(Jn. 15:13). A mother who demonstrates this in a particularly striking way is
Saint Gianna Beretta Molla, who died in 1962 and was declared "blessed" by Pope
John Paul II on April 24, 1994 [and canonized on May 16, 2004]. She was a doctor
and mother of three children. When she became pregnant with her fourth, it was
discovered that she had a tumor near her uterus. She made it very clear to her
doctor and her family that she wanted everything done to save the life of her
baby. The baby was born healthy but despite efforts to save her, Gianna died
several days later at the age of 39. "This is absurd," some may say. But look
again at the words of Our Lord Jesus Christ. "Greater love than this no one has,
than to lay down his life for his friends" (Jn.15:13).
Most parents will not be called to face what Gianna Molla faced, but all
parents, and all Christians, are called to lay down their lives for the sake of
others in so many ways every day. Let us pray especially for mothers who are
afraid of motherhood, and who are tempted to abort their children. Let us pray
that they aecept the grace to love as Christ has loved us. God will never place
an obligation before us without also giving us every ounce of strength we need
to carry it through. Let us praise Him for His grace, for His love, and for the
victory of Life! Amen.
Partial List of Individual Scripture references
Gen. 1:1-2,26-28 Creation of man
Gen. 2:7-8,18,21-24 Creation of man and woman
Gen. 4:8-16 The first killing of the innocent
Ex. 20:1-17 The Decalogue
Lev. 19:15-18 Love of your neighbor’s life
Deut. 30:15-20 Choose Life!
Jeremiah 7:27-31 The rebuke of child sacrifice
Ezekiel 23:36-39 Child sacrifice
Wisdom 1:12-15 God did not make death.
Wisdom 7:1-6 I was formed in the womb.
2 Kings 24:1-4 The exile occurred because innocent blood was shed.
Proverbs 6:16-19 The Lord hates six things.
Jeremiah 1:4-8 I called you from the womb.
Isaiah 49:1-6 The Lord called me from the womb.
Isaiah 49:14-17 Can a mother forget her infant?
Isaiah 1:10-17 Do justice!
Amos 5:21-24 Let justice roll down like a river!
Psalm 72 He will save the weak from violence!
Psalm 82 Rescue the weak!
Psalm 139 You knit me together in the womb!
Proverbs 24:8-12 Rescue those taken to death!
Matt. 18:1-6,10-14 Do not despise the little ones.
Matt. 25:31-46 Whatsoever you do to the least...
Mark 10:13-16 He blessed children.
Luke 1:39-45 The babe leapt in the womb.
Luke 6:20-26 Beatitudes and woes
Luke 10:29-37 The Good Samaritan is neighbor to anyone in need.
Luke 16:19-31 The Lazarus of the 20th Century: The Unborn Child
John 1:1-5 All things, all life, comes through Christ.
John 10:7-15 The Good Shepherd came to give us life.
John 11:17-27 Christ is the Life.
John 14:1-6 Christ is the Life.
1 Cor. 15:51-58 The victory belongs to life; you do not labor in vain.
Eph. 6:10-20 Be strong in this battle!
James 1:22-27 Religion requires us to help the helpless.
1 John 3:11-18 Love rather than kill.
Rev. 4:8-11 You have created all things.
Rev. 21:1-5 Death shall be no more!
Doctrinal Starting Points
Our commitment to defend our pre-born brothers and sisters receives its
form and sustenance from the Eucharist as a sacrament of faith, unity, life,
worship, and love.
The Eucharist is a sacrament of faith. The Consecrated Host looks no
different after the consecration than before. It looks, smells, feels, and
tastes like bread. Only one of the five senses gets to the truth. As St. Thomas'
Adoro Te Devote expresses, "Seeing, touching, tasting are in Thee
deceived. What says trusty hearing, that shall be believed?" The ears hear His
words, "This is My Body; this is My Blood," and faith takes us beyond the veil
Christians are used to looking beyond appearances. The baby in the manger
does not look like God; nor for that matter does the man on the cross. Yet by
faith we know He is no mere man. The Bible does not have a particular glow
setting it off from other books, nor does it levitate above the shelf. Yet by
faith we know it is uniquely the Word of God. The Eucharist seems to be bread
and wine, and yet by faith we say, "My Lord and My God!" as we kneel in
The same dynamic of faith that enables us to see beyond appearances in
these mysteries enables us to see beyond appearances in our neighbor. We can
look at the persons around us, at the annoying person or the ugly person or the
person who is unconscious in a hospital bed, and we can say, "Christ is there as
well. There is my bother, my sister, made in the very image of God!" By the same
dynamic we can look at the pre-born child and say, "There, too, is my brother,
my sister, equal in dignity and just as worthy of protection as anyone else!"
Some people will say the child in the womb, especially in the earliest stages,
is too small to be the subject of Constitutional rights. Is the Sacred Host too
small to be God, too unlike Him in appearance to be worshipped? The slightest
particle of the Host is fully Christ. Eucharistic Faith is a powerful antidote
to the dangerous notion that value depends on size.
The Eucharist is also a Sacrament of Unity. "When I am lifted up from the
earth," the Lord said, "I will draw all people to myself" (Jn.12:32). He
fulfills this promise in the Eucharist, which builds up the Church. The Church
is the sign and cause of the unity of the human family.
Imagine all the people, in every part of the world, who are receiving
Communion today. Are they all receiving their own personalized, customized
Christ? Are they not rather each receiving the one and only Christ? Through this
sacrament, Christ the Lord, gloriously enthroned in heaven, is drawing all
people to Himself. If He is drawing us to Himself, then He is drawing us to one
another. St. Paul comments on this, "We, many though we are, are one body, since
we all partake of the one loaf" (1 Cor. 10:17). When we call each other
"brothers and sisters," we are not merely using a metaphor that dimly reflects
the unity between children of the same parents. The unity we have in Christ is
even stronger than the unity of blood brothers and sisters, because we do have
common blood: the blood of Christ! The result of the Eucharist is that we become
one, and this obliges us to be as concerned for each other as we are for our own
Imagine a person who receives Communion, accepts the Host when the priest
says, "The Body of Christ," says "Amen," and then breaks off a piece, hands it
back, and says, "Except this piece, Father!" This is what the person who rejects
other people may as well do. In receiving Christ, we are to receive the whole
Christ, in all his members, our brothers and sisters, whether convenient or
inconvenient, wanted or unwanted.
As St. John remarks, Christ was to die "to gather into one all the
scattered children of God." Sin scatters. Christ unites. The word "diabolical"
means "to split asunder." Christ came "to destroy the works of the devil"
(1Jn.3:8). The Eucharist builds up the human family in Christ who says, "Come to
me, feed on My Body, become My Body." Abortion, in a reverse dynamic, says, "Go
away! We have no room for you, no time for you, no desire for you, no
responsibility for you. Get out of our way!" Abortion attacks the unity of the
human family by splitting asunder the most fundamental relationship between any
two persons: mother and child. The Eucharist, as a Sacrament of Unity, reverses
the dynamic of abortion.
The Eucharist is the Sacrament of Life. "I am the Bread of Life. He who
eats this bread will live forever. I will raise Him up on the last day." (See
Jn.6:47-58) The Eucharistic sacrifice is the very action of Christ by which He
destroyed our death and restored our life. Whenever we gather for this sacrifice
we are celebrating the victory of life over death, and therefore over abortion.
The pro-life movement is not simply working "for" victory; we are working "from"
victory. As the Holy Father said in Denver in 1993, "Have no fear. The outcome
of the battle for life is already decided." Our work is to apply the already
established victory to every facet of our society. Celebrating the Eucharist is
the source and summit of such work.
The Eucharist is the Supreme act of Worship of God. Two lessons each
person needs to learn are, "1.There is a God. 2. It isn't me." The Eucharist, as
the perfect sacrifice, acknowledges that God is God, and that "it is [His] right
to receive the obedience of all creation." (Sacramentary, Preface for Weekdays
III). Abortion, on the contrary, proclaims that a mother's choice is supreme.
"Freedom of choice" is considered enough to justify even the dismemberment of a
baby. Choice divorced from truth is idolatry. It is the opposite of true
worship. It pretends the creature is God. Real freedom is found only in
submission to the truth and will of God. Real freedom is not the ability to do
whatever one pleases, but the power to do what is right.
The Eucharist is, finally, The Sacrament of Love. St. John explains,
"This is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us"
(1Jn.3:16). Christ teaches, "Greater love than this no one has, than to lay down
his life for his friends" (Jn.15:13). The best symbol of love is not the heart,
but rather the crucifix.
Abortion is the exact opposite of love. Love says, "I sacrifice myself
for the good of the other person. Abortion says, "I sacrifice the other person
for the good of myself." In the Eucharist we see the meaning of love and receive
the power to live it. The very same words, furthermore, that the Lord uses to
teach us the meaning of love are also used by those who promote abortion: "This
is my body." These four little words are spoken from opposite ends of the
universe, with totally opposite results. Christ gives His body away so others
might live; abortion supporters cling to their own bodies so others might die.
Christ says "This is My Body given up for you; This is My Blood shed for you."
These are the words of sacrifice; these are the words of love.
In Washington in 1994 Mother Teresa said that we fight abortion by
teaching the mother what love really means: "to be willing to give until it
hurts...So, the mother who is thinking of abortion, should be helped to love,
that is, to give until it hurts her plans, or her free time, to respect the life
of her child."
Gustave Thibon has said that the true God transforms violence into
suffering, while the false god transforms suffering into violence. The woman
tempted to have an abortion will transform her suffering into violence unless
she allows love to transform her, and make her willing to give herself away. The
Eucharist gives both the lesson and the power. Mom is to say "This is my body,
my blood, my life, given up for you my child."
Everyone who wants to fight abortion needs to say the same. We need to
exercise the same generosity we ask the mothers to exercise. We need to imitate
the mysteries we celebrate. "Do this in memory of me" applies to all of us in
the sense that we are to lovingly suffer with Christ so others may live. We are
to be like lightning rods in the midst of this terrible storm of violence and
destruction, and say, "Yes, Lord, I am willing to absorb some of this violence
and transform it by love into personal suffering, so that others may live."
Indeed, the Eucharist gives the pro-life movement its marching orders. It
also provides the source of its energy, which is love. Indeed, if the pro-life
movement is not a movement of love, then it is nothing at all. But if it is a
movement of love, then nothing will stop it, for "Love is stronger than death,
more powerful even than hell" (Song of Songs 8:6).
The Holy Spirit
No new gospel
The Holy Spirit is God, and all He does and speaks to us is consistent with
what God the Father and God the Son have done and spoken. "He will not speak
on his own, but will speak only what he hears…because he will have received from
me what he will announce to you" (Jn. 16:13-14) "The Holy Spirit…will…remind
you of all that I told you" (Jn.14:26). No disciple can claim the "freedom of
the Spirit" to contradict the commandments, including that which forbids the
killing of the innocent.
The creation account in Genesis 1 tells us that "a mighty wind," the "breath"
or "spirit" of God hovered over the waters and brought life and light out of
chaos and darkness. The Holy Spirit is proclaimed in the Creed to be "the Lord
and Giver of Life," and this is true both on a natural and supernatural level.
To worship the Holy Spirit, then, demands that we stand against all that
On the first Easter night, Jesus breathes His Spirit upon the apostles
(Jn.20:22), that they too might bring new life out of the chaos and darkness of
sin. A second Creation account is taking place here. God indeed "has sent the
Holy Spirit among us for the forgiveness of sins" (Prayer of Absolution). The
same Spirit who causes sin to flee will cause death to flee as well. "If the
Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, then he who raised
Christ from the dead will bring your mortal bodies to life also, through his
Spirit dwelling in you" (Rom.8:11).
The Spirit of Truth
The Holy Spirit is called the Spirit of Truth (see Jn.15:26), and His gifts
enable us to understand created realities, their value, and their relationship
to the Creator and to our own happiness. We can therefore ask the Holy Spirit to
give us an understanding of the value of the human person. The Spirit enables us
to cry out, "Abba! Father!" "The Spirit himself gives witness with our spirit
that we are children of God" (Rom.8:16). Abortion, on the other hand, sees the
human person as a disposable object.
The Spirit of Truth likewise shows us the truth about our sins (see Jn.16:8).
In Him we come to understand the difference between good and evil. This works
directly against the dynamics of the abortion movement, which identifies a moral
evil as a "right." "Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil, who change
darkness into light, and light into darkness, who change bitter into sweet, and
sweet into bitter!" (Is.5:20). Devotion to the Holy Spirit is a key element in
praying for the conversion of mind and heart necessary for those who defend and
St. John declares, "If anyone should sin, we have, in the presence of the
Father, Jesus Christ, an intercessor who is just" (1Jn.2:1). Our Lord referred
to the Holy Spirit as another advocate (Jn.14:16), and St. Paul writes that he
"makes intercession for us" (Rom.8:26). Because we cannot save ourselves, we
need an advocate to speak up on our behalf and plead for our forgiveness and
salvation. We know we have precisely that.
What, then, does the Holy Spirit do to his people when he comes to them? He
makes them advocates! He gives speech to the tongue, not only that we may tell
who God is, but that we may defend those among us who need advocates. The
Pentecost Sequence invokes the Spirit as "Father of the Poor." Just as the
Messiah will defend the poor and helpless (see Is.11), so do the people of the
Messiah, filled with his Spirit.
Spirit of Love
Jesus Christ made the sacrifice of Himself "through the eternal spirit"
(Heb.9:14). It is in the Holy Spirit that we too have the power to love, which
consists in giving ourselves away for the good of the other. "There is no
greater love than this: to lay down one's life for one's friends" (Jn. 15:13,
see also 1Jn.3:16). Such is to be our response to the unborn.
The Spirit Himself is the bond of love between the Father and the Son. He
unites the human family, whereas abortion divides it.
The Virgin Mary
There is one Mediator…
Some Christians question why we give so much devotion to the Blessed Virgin
Mary, and claim that it compromises the unique worship which Christ alone
deserves. We do not, of course, "worship" Mary in any sense. She, too, is a
creature, and all her importance flows from the uniqueness of Christ.
But how is it that Christ became the unique Mediator? A mediator is a bridge
between the two parties being mediated, in this case, God and humanity. Christ
was God from all eternity. It is precisely in taking upon Himself a human nature
that He becomes the Mediator. This human nature is taken from Mary. The
very fact that Christ is the one Mediator demonstrates the critical role of the
one Mother from whom He became human.
All the importance of Mary flows from her Son, and worship of the Son
naturally leads to honoring the Mother. Right from this fundamental point,
Marian devotion teaches us something about our pro-life commitment. Mother
and child belong together.
The difference between the pro-abortion side and the pro-life side is not
that they favor women's rights and we love the baby. The real difference is that
they think you can separate the two and we say you can't. The pro-abortion
mentality claims you can love the mother while killing the child. The pro-life
mentality asserts that you can't harm one without harming the other and you
can't love one without loving the other. The pro-life position has never been,
"Love the baby and forget about the mother." It is rather, always and only,
"Let's love them both."
Mary was conceived without Original Sin. This favor was granted to her in
anticipation of her role as the Mother of God. A fundamental truth that appears
here, and is reflected in various Scriptures, is the relationship of God with
the child in the womb and the manner in which he prepares that child for his/her
This doctrine likewise proclaims to us the broader truth about victory over
sin. Mary was not exempt from the need of a Savior; He simply shared with her in
a unique way the victory over sin which He offers all of us.
Those who have abortions do not have them because of "freedom of choice," but
rather because they feel they have no freedom and no choice. Mountains of
pressure and confusion fall upon them. Yet in the struggle against temptation
and sin, there is always sufficient grace to do what is right. "God keeps his
promise. "He will not let you be tested beyond your strength. Along with the
test he will give you a way out of it so that you may be able to endure it"
(1Cor10:13). This conviction is a key tool to help those who are tempted and to
encourage those who counsel others against abortion.
Mary faces an unplanned pregnancy. Her response is Let it be done to me
according to your word. She freely chooses to accept the Child, but in doing
so, acknowledges the primacy of the word. In other words, the truth of
God's Word exists before her own choosing. She submits to a word, a truth, she
did not create. At the heart of the "pro-choice" mentality is the idea that we
create our own truth. For example, the value of the unborn child, and
that child's very right to exist, depends upon the choice of the mother.
In the pro-life mentality, on the other hand, the choice of the
mother must respect the truth of the inherent value of the child, which
does not in any way flow from or depend upon us. Let it be done to me
according to your word.
As we submit to that truth, God does not rob us of our freedom. Instead, He
lifts it up to Himself.
Mary's Practical Charity
Mary was firmly rooted in the truth and in charity. When she received
Gabriel's message and learned she would be the mother of God, she did not lose
sight of the pressing needs of her kinswoman Elizabeth. She undertook the
arduous journey to the hill country, and tended to Elizabeth's needs for three
months. (See Lk.1:39-56). Mary kept in touch with both heavenly and earthly
reality. The truth of her new status did not distract her from Elizabeth's
needs. Mary responded to those needs in a very practical way. The same happened
at Cana. The celebration there in company with Christ and the Apostles did not
blind her to the real needs of the newlyweds. And she responded.
Union with God does not turn us in on ourselves. Authentic holiness makes us
more aware of and responsive to the real needs of others. The pro-life movement
responds to the real needs of real children and their mothers. We provide these
mothers with the concrete medical, financial, psychological, and spiritual help
they need. Nothing distracts us. This is Marian pro-life ministry.
There is an axiom in psychiatry that says, "Believe behavior." See what the
speaker does. The "pro-choice" (pro-abortion) movement masks over reality, and
for all its rhetoric leaves women only three things: a scarred mind, a wounded
body, and a dead baby. The pro-life movement, through more than 3000 helping
centers throughout the nation, offers women real help in their need, and the
gift of life. We learned this from a very special Mother.
Assumed into Heaven
The Assumption speaks of the victory of Life over death. "Today the virgin
Mother of God was taken up into heaven to be the beginning and the pattern of
the Church in its perfection..."(P59). The Assumption is not only about Mary;
it's about us. Mary has a unique privilege. Being the Mother of God, she was
taken at once into glory upon the completion of her earthly life. Yet the entire
Church is the Body of Christ. As we pray on the Ascension, "where He has gone,
we hope to follow" (Preface of the Ascension, P26). We, too, are called to share
an everlasting life, in body and soul, in the company of Christ and all who are
saved. "I will raise him up on the last day" (Jn. 6:54).
The conviction, renewed by the Assumption, that the destiny of the human
person is to be in the heights of heaven, is clearly incompatible with allowing
human persons to be thrown in the garbage.
Seasonal Starting Points
Pro-Life Themes in the Advent Liturgy
The introduction to the lectionary, when speaking of the Sundays
of Advent, says, "Each gospel reading has a specific theme: the Lord's coming in
glory at the end of time (first Sunday), John the Baptist (second and third
Sundays), and the events which immediately prepared for the Lord's birth (fourth
We focus, in other words, on the first and second comings of the same Christ,
and on the one who teaches us how to prepare for His arrival, namely, by
repentance. "Reform your lives! The reign of God is at hand." The New Testament
readings complement and expand on John the Baptist's exhortations of repentance.
St. Paul urges, "Let us cast off deeds of darkness" (1 Advent A), and "Live in
perfect harmony with one another" (2d Advent A), He speaks of faith as an
obedience (4th Advent A). St. James encourages, "Be patient .... Steady your
hearts" (3rd Advent A). The Old Testament prophets, furthermore, describe the
results of the Messiah's coming, "One nation shall not raise the sword against
the other" (1 Advent A), "There shall be no harm or ruin on all my holy
mountain" (2d Advent A). "Then will the eyes of the blind be opened ... sorrow
and mourning will flee" (3rd Advent A). "Immanuel" (4th Advent A).
The preparation for Christ's coming is reform, and the promise of His coming
is reconciliation. The two, furthermore, are linked. If the Messiah comes to
restore harmony between nations, people, and even animals ("Then the wolf shall
be a guest of the lamb.... the baby shall play by the cobra's den"), then the
people of the Messiah are to repent of whatever destroys that harmony. If the
Messiah comes to bring justice ("He shall judge the poor with justice and decide
aright for the land's afflicted"), then the people of the Messiah are to work to
eliminate injustice. The "justice" referred to in Isaiah 11 is an act of
intervention to save the helpless. The "spirit of the Lord" which rests on the
Messiah and likewise on His people, leads them to and prepares them for the work
of justice, as the structure of this passage indicates. This same Spirit will
later be called the Advocate.
Abortion is an injustice against the most helpless, and attacks the harmony
of human relationships at their most fundamental and sensitive point, the
relationship of mother and child. Preparing for the Lord's coming therefore
requires a total rejection of abortion. The promise of His coming heralds a new
harmony between mother and child. The focus on the Virgin and Child at the end
of Advent highlights this.
The Second Vatican Council reflects upon the relationship between the coming
of Christ and our activity to prepare for it. In the Constitution on the
Church in the Modern World, we read, "Far from diminishing our concern to
develop this earth, the expectancy of a new earth should spur us on, for it is
here that the body of a new human family grows, foreshadowing in some way the
age which is to come.... When we have spread on earth the fruits of our nature
and our enterprise -- human dignity, brotherly communion and freedom --
according to the command of the Lord and in his Spirit, we will find them once
again, cleansed this time from the stain of sin, illuminated and transfigured,
when Christ presents to his Father an eternal and universal kingdom...." (#39).
In other words, the spirit of Advent should naturally bolster our pro-life
efforts, and the progress we make in promoting human dignity becomes the
"building blocks" for the eternal kingdom.
Advent leads the Church to the Silent Night when God Himself is revealed as
one of us. This season leads us to the joy of His birth (which, incidentally, is
the opening theme of The Gospel of Life). If God has joined His nature to
ours, how can we ever allow our nature to be despised? If He has come to bring
us Divine Life, and will return to take us to the skies, how can it be all right
to throw people in the garbage? May His birth shed protection on all about to be
born, and as we work to end abortion, may we "wait in joyful hope for the coming
of Our Savior, Jesus Christ."
Pro-Life Themes for Lent
"Each year you give us this joyful season when we prepare to celebrate
the paschal mystery with mind and heart renewed." (Preface of Lent 1).
The purpose of Lent is succinctly expressed by this preface. Catechumens
prepare for baptism into the paschal mystery. The faithful are reminded of their
baptism, and will renew their baptismal vows at the Easter liturgy.
This baptismal focus is a life focus, and is illumined by Lenten readings
as well as by the encyclical, The Gospel of Life.
Baptism initiates us into the eternal life Christ gives us. 'Eternal'
does not only mean it never ends. It also refers to the "quality" of that life,
namely, it is a share in the life of the Eternal God.
The baptized, therefore, are sons and daughters of God and are members of
the Church, the People of Life (see Evangelium Vitae #79). The baptized
have taken hold of the eternal life promised them (see Rom.6:4) and are already
living it (Gal 2:19-20; John 6:47).
The choices of the baptized are therefore to be shaped by their new
identity (see Rom 6:6; Eph. 4:17-24). We see how Christ calls the Samaritan
woman to repent as she accepts the waters of new life (see John 4:15-24). Lenten
repentance is necessary so that God's people may more deeply become who they
are. They are called to see their sins more clearly. Hence baptism is known as
"illumination." The passage about the man born blind (John 9) is therefore a key
Lenten passage (4th Sunday of Lent-A and optional Mass for 4th week of Lent).
Anyone who makes the Lenten journey is called to be more alert to the
attacks on human life and dignity around them. The people of life are called to
reject sin and all the devil's works and empty promises (Renewal of Baptismal
Promises, Easter Liturgy). The "pro-choice" and "right to die" mentalities are
two of those "empty promises" which are firmly rejected by the baptized. A firm
rejection of these positions is integral to repentance. Lent is the perfect time
for us to call our congregations to a clearer understanding of why this is true,
and to lead them to a deeper affirmation of life, both natural and eternal, in
the celebration of the Paschal Mystery.
Homily on Pro-Life During the Easter Season
Christ is Risen! "Death has no more power over Him!" (Rom.6:9) The central
fact of human history and the foundational truth of our Faith is celebrated in
the Easter Season. "Jesus Christ broke the chains of death and rose triumphant
from the tomb" (Easter Proclamation).
He broke the chains of death, furthermore, not only for Himself but for us!
If someone who died in your town were seen alive again, it would be an
astonishing event, but it would leave our lives, and the prospect of our death,
unchanged. But when Jesus Christ rose from the dead he overthrew the entire
kingdom of death. He robbed death of its power! By his Resurrection, He opened
the door for our resurrection! God is in the business of destroying
prophesied (Is.25:8). "O death, I will be your death" Hosea foretold
Since we are God's people, we are the people of life. We bear witness to what
God continues to do in our midst. We stand against death in all its forms. It’s
most destructive form, both in principle and statistically, is abortion. The
People of Life cannot ignore the taking of life. The People of Life cannot
espouse death as a legitimate option to solve a problem. Nor, in fighting the
power of death, can they ever doubt the outcome. Christ is Risen, Life is
A Tragedy beyond words
Ultimately, our people need to see the reality behind the word
"abortion." We are a visual society. The word "abortion" has lost its meaning
for people, because they have in their mind a far more benign, innocuous notion
of abortion than what it actually is. Words alone cannot describe its horror.
Unless people appreciate the horror of abortion, they will not feel the
appropriate sense of outrage that it deserves. Without an appropriate sense of
outrage, people seldom take personal responsibility for ending injustice. Many
think we are over-reacting to abortion. We need to help them see that they are
Therefore we recommend that every possible and appropriate means be taken
to show people the reality of the unborn child and the destructive act of
abortion. Videos of ultrasound and fetoscopy, as well as actual scenes of
abortion and aborted children are available (A Window to the Womb, The
Silent Scream, Eclipse of Reason, Harder Truth).
Preaching is to serve the ongoing conversion and growth in holiness of
the people entrusted to our pastoral care. A "pastor" is a "shepherd". To
shepherd our people in an age of abortion requires preachers who will be clear
and courageous in confronting evil, and likewise calm and compassionate in
calling back those who have committed evil. It involves not only getting people
to think the right way about things like abortion, but it involves inspiring and
equipping them to take action to stop such evils. This is a challenging art, and
an urgent need.
It is a mission for which we will never be lacking all the tools and
grace we need.
Priests for Life Resources for Preaching on abortion
The preceding pages only scratch the surface of the critical topic of
preaching about abortion. For information which is continuously updated, and
which may be even more suitable for your concrete circumstances, we invite you
to use the following resources:
Priests for Life Website -- www.priestsforlife.org The website,
updated daily, contains printed material as well as audio and video resources,
and a wide range of links to other groups. The specific section on preaching is
found at www.priestsforlife.org/preaching
Our network of priests and deacons -- Our full-time staff of priests
and lay experts is in contact with priests and pro-life leaders across the
nation every day. We are available for individual consultation, and may be able
to put you in touch with other priests in situations similar to your own, who
can assist with their experience and advice. Call us at 888-PFL-3448.
Newsletter subscription -- Our newsletter is available by mail, on the
website, or through email. Homily suggestions are regularly featured, including
submissions by priests from around the country.
Seminars -- Our full time priests travel the nation to conduct
seminars on preaching, counseling, and organizing activities to promote the
pro-life cause. Inquire at our office about the possibility of hosting such a
Audio tapes, including scriptural retreats -- These resources can be
heard by RealAudio on our website at
www.priestsforlife.org/broadcasting.html or ordered directly from us.